Q10. How is the Indian concept of secularism different from the Western model of secularism? Discuss.

Model Answer:

Introduction

The Indian concept of secularism differs from the Western model in its approach to religion, state involvement, and pluralism, reflecting unique historical, cultural, and social contexts.

Body

1. Definition 

• Western Model: In the West, secularism often refers to the strict separation of church and state, where religion is kept out of public affairs. This concept emerged primarily from the Enlightenment and the need to limit the influence of organized religion in governance.
• Indian Model: Indian secularism is characterized by the state’s active involvement in promoting and protecting all religions. It evolved from India’s historical context of religious diversity, colonial rule, and the need for social harmony among various faiths.

2. Relationship Between Religion and State

• Western Model: The state functions independently of religious institutions, ensuring that policies and laws are free from religious influence. The goal is to create a neutral public sphere where all beliefs are treated equally.
• Indian Model: The Indian state recognizes and respects the significance of various religions in public life. It engages with religions, intervening when necessary to maintain social order and equality among communities, such as through laws protecting minority rights.

3. Pluralism and Inclusivity

• Western Model: While Western secularism promotes freedom of belief, it tends to emphasize individual rights over communal identities. This model may inadvertently marginalize religious communities if their practices conflict with secular norms.
• Indian Model: Indian secularism embraces pluralism, acknowledging the importance of community identities. It aims to create an environment where diverse religious practices coexist and thrive, fostering mutual respect and understanding among different groups.

4. Legal Framework and Policy Implementation

• Western Model: Laws are generally designed to uphold secularism by prohibiting any form of religious favouritism or discrimination in public institutions. Court rulings often focus on protecting individual freedoms.
• Indian Model: Indian laws reflect an effort to balance the interests of various communities. The Constitution guarantees the right to freely practice religion and includes provisions for affirmative action to uplift marginalized groups, demonstrating a commitment to social justice.

Conclusion

In summary, Indian secularism is more integrative and community-focused, contrasting with the Western emphasis on separation and individualism, reflecting India’s diverse and complex societal landscape.

‍

Instant Mains Evaluation with SuperKalam

✅ Now that you have gone through the model answer, try practicing and writing it in your own words and evaluate it instantly with SuperKalam here - Evaluate Mains Answer instantly