The idea of justice is not static as it evolves with social values, awareness, legal frameworks, and moral progress. What is considered just or fair at one point in time may be reevaluated as unjust. This dynamic nature of justice makes critical reflection and continuous ethical scrutiny essential to prevent failure of justice system.

Contextual Nature of Justice

• The concept of justice is intrinsically linked to societal values, which are subject to change. Aristotle's virtue ethics emphasizes the importance of context in determining virtuous actions, suggesting that what constitutes justice can vary.

  Example: Section 377 of IPC (LGBTQ Rights) - Until 2018, homosexuality was criminalized in India. Supreme Court decriminalized it, recognizing the right to dignity, privacy, and equality.

• Changing Social Norms: Societal values shift, leading to reinterpretations of justice.

  Example: Marital rape, once legally permissible in many countries, is now increasingly criminalized.

• Technological Advancements: New technologies create novel ethical dilemmas that require adjustments to existing legal and moral frameworks.

  Example: The development of AI raises questions about algorithmic bias and its impact on fairness and equality necessitating new regulations and ethical guidelines.

• Increased Awareness and Advocacy: Social movements and advocacy groups play a crucial role in highlighting injustices and pushing for legal and social change.

  Example: The Vishaka Guidelines, resulting from Bhanwari Devi's gang rape case, established legal provisions against sexual harassment in the workplace in India.

Importance of Constant Scrutiny of Concept of Jusitce.

• Constant scrutiny of existing laws and practices is crucial for ensuring that the justice system remains relevant and effective.

• Preventing Miscarriage of Justice: Scrutiny helps identify and rectify outdated laws or practices that perpetuate injustice.

  Example: the Bengal Sati Regulation of 1829 outlawed Sati Practice hiterto considered as Norm.

• Maintaining Social Order: Adapting laws to reflect changing societal values helps maintain social cohesion and stability.

  Example: The legalization of same-sex marriage in many countries reflects a growing societal acceptance and promotes social inclusion.

• Promoting Equity and Fairness: Scrutiny ensures that the justice system treats all individuals fairly, regardless of their background or circumstances.

  Example: Educational and Employment reservation for SC and ST communities in India.

• Reflect Moral Progress: Societies evolve with time and Justice must keep pace with this moral evolution or risk becoming regressive.

  Example: The growing acceptance of gender-neutral laws reflects a shift from binary thinking to inclusivity.

Continuous evaluation of legal and ethical frameworks is essential to ensure that justice remains relevant and effective in a dynamic world. This requires a commitment to incorporating evolving societal values and addressing emerging challenges through thoughtful dialogue, policy reforms, and judicial interpretation, thereby ensuring a just and equitable society for all.