You are heading a district administration in a particular department. Your senior officer calls you from the State Headquarters and tells you that a plot in Rampur village is to have a building constructed on it for a school. A visit is scheduled during which he will visit the site along with the chief engineer and the senior architect. He wants you to check out all the papers relating to it and ensure that the visit is properly arranged. You examine the file which relates to the period before you joined the department. The land was acquired for the local panchayat at a nominal cost and the papers showed that clearance certificates are available for the two of the three authorities who have to certify the site’s suitability. There is no certification by the architect available on file. You decide to visit Rampur to ensure that all is in the order as stated on file. When you visit Rampur, you find that the plot under reference is a part of Thakurgarh fort and that the walls, ramparts, etc., are running across it. The fort is well away from the main village, therefore a school here will be a serious inconvenience for the children. However, the area near the village has potential to expand into a larger residential area. The development charges on the existing plot, at the fort, will be very high and question of heritage site has not been addressed. Moreover, the Sarpanch, at the time of acquisition of the land, was a relative of your predecessor. The whole transaction appears to have been done with some vested interest.
(a) List the likely vested interests of the concerned parties.
(b) Some of the options for action available to you are listed below. Discuss the merits and demerits of each of the options:
(i) You can await the visit of the superior officer and let him make a decision.
(ii) You can seek his advice in writing or on the phone.
(iii) You can consult your predecessor/ colleagues, etc, and then decide what to do.
(iv) You can find out if any alternate plot can be got in exchange and then send a comprehensive written report.
Can you suggest any other option with proper justifications?
You are heading a district administration in a particular department. Your senior officer calls you from the State Headquarters and tells you that a plot in Rampur village is to have a building constructed on it for a school. A visit is scheduled during which he will visit the site along with the chief engineer and the senior architect. He wants you to check out all the papers relating to it and ensure that the visit is properly arranged. You examine the file which relates to the period before you joined the department. The land was acquired for the local panchayat at a nominal cost and the papers showed that clearance certificates are available for the two of the three authorities who have to certify the site’s suitability. There is no certification by the architect available on file. You decide to visit Rampur to ensure that all is in the order as stated on file. When you visit Rampur, you find that the plot under reference is a part of Thakurgarh fort and that the walls, ramparts, etc., are running across it. The fort is well away from the main village, therefore a school here will be a serious inconvenience for the children. However, the area near the village has potential to expand into a larger residential area. The development charges on the existing plot, at the fort, will be very high and question of heritage site has not been addressed. Moreover, the Sarpanch, at the time of acquisition of the land, was a relative of your predecessor. The whole transaction appears to have been done with some vested interest.
(a) List the likely vested interests of the concerned parties.
(b) Some of the options for action available to you are listed below. Discuss the merits and demerits of each of the options:
(i) You can await the visit of the superior officer and let him make a decision.
(ii) You can seek his advice in writing or on the phone.
(iii) You can consult your predecessor/ colleagues, etc, and then decide what to do.
(iv) You can find out if any alternate plot can be got in exchange and then send a comprehensive written report.
Can you suggest any other option with proper justifications?
The case presents a complex administrative dilemma involving heritage site violation, procedural irregularities, and potential corruption in land acquisition for educational infrastructure. The discovery of the plot being part of Thakurgarh fort with incomplete clearances and questionable acquisition process creates significant ethical and legal challenges for public administration.
Stakeholders
- Primary Stakeholders: District administration, senior officer, children of Rampur village, local panchayat, heritage authorities
- Secondary Stakeholders: Chief engineer, senior architect, predecessor officer, Sarpanch, broader community, Archaeological Survey of India
(a) Likely Vested Interests of Concerned Parties
- Predecessor Officer: Personal financial gain through land deal facilitation, maintaining relationships with local influential families, potential kickbacks from inflated land prices
- Sarpanch (Relative): Monetary benefits from land transaction, increased property values in surrounding areas, political leverage through infrastructure project control
- Local Panchayat Members: Commission from development contracts, preferential treatment for future projects, maintaining political networks
- Land Brokers/Middlemen: Transaction fees, future business opportunities, establishing connections with administrative officials
- Construction Contractors: Securing lucrative building contracts, inflated project costs due to heritage site complications, long-term business relationships
(b) Options Available with Merits and Demerits
Option (i): Await superior officer's visit and let him decide
| Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|
| Avoids immediate responsibility and potential conflict | Enables continuation of potentially illegal heritage site violation |
| Maintains hierarchical protocol and administrative chain | Wastes public resources on unsuitable location |
| Protects from accusations of insubordination | Compromises children's educational accessibility and safety |
Option (ii): Seek advice in writing or on phone
| Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|
| Creates documented trail of communication | May pressure superior to make hasty decisions |
| Shares responsibility while maintaining transparency | Could strain professional relationships if issues are sensitive |
| Enables informed decision-making with ground reality | Might not convey complete complexity of heritage violations |
Option (iii): Consult predecessor/colleagues before deciding
| Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|
| Gains institutional knowledge and historical context | Risk of cover-up advice from potentially complicit parties |
| Builds consensus among administrative peers | May compromise investigation integrity |
| Reduces isolation in decision-making process | Could alert involved parties to ongoing scrutiny |
Option (iv): Find alternate plot and send comprehensive report
| Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|
| Provides practical solution while exposing irregularities | Requires significant time and resource investment |
| Protects heritage site and ensures educational accessibility | May face resistance from vested interest groups |
| Demonstrates proactive administrative leadership | Could delay school construction project timeline |
Additional Option: Immediate Heritage Authority Consultation with Parallel Investigation
- Justification: Contact Archaeological Survey of India immediately while initiating internal inquiry through vigilance department
- Constitutional Basis: Article 51A(f) mandates heritage protection; Article 21A ensures children's education rights
- Administrative Protocol: Follow Central Vigilance Commission guidelines for corruption investigation while maintaining RTI Act transparency
Course of Action
- Immediate: Halt all proceedings, document heritage site evidence, inform ASI and State Heritage Committee
- Short-term: File detailed report with photographic evidence, request alternate land identification, initiate preliminary inquiry against predecessor
- Long-term: Establish heritage clearance protocols, implement transparent land acquisition procedures, create community consultation mechanisms for future projects
The ethical imperative demands protecting both cultural heritage and children's educational rights while ensuring administrative accountability. "The true test of civilization is not the census, nor the size of cities, but the kind of man the country turns out."
Answer Length
Model answers may exceed the word limit for better clarity and depth. Use them as a guide, but always frame your final answer within the exam’s prescribed limit.
Ethics: Case Study PYQs from 2015
- 25 MarksView Answer
You are recently posted as district development officer of a district. Shortly thereafter you found that there is considerable tension in the rural areas of your district on the issue of sending girls to schools. The elders of the village feel that many problems have come up because girls are being educated and they are stepping out of the safe environment of the household. They are the view that girls should be quickly married off with minimum education. The girls are also competing for jobs after education, which have traditionally remained in boys’ exclusive domain, adding to unemployment amongst the male population. The younger generation feels that in the present era, girls should have equal opportunities for education employment, and other means of livelihood. The entire locality is divided between sexes in both generations. You come to know that in Panchayat or in other local bodies or even in busy crosswords, the issue is being acrimoniously debated. One day you are informed that an unpleasant incident has taken place. Some girls were molested when they were en route to school. The incident led to clashes between several groups and a law and order problem has arisen. The elder after heated discussion has taken a joint decision not to allow girls to go to school and to socially boycott all such families, which do not follow their dictate.
(a) What steps would you take to ensure girls’ safety without disrupting their education?
(b) How would you manage and mold the patriarchic attitude of the village elders to ensure harmony in inter-generational relations? - 20 MarksView Answer
There is a disaster-prone state having frequent landslides, forest fires, cloudbursts, flash floods and earthquakes, etc. Some of these are seasonal and often unpredictable. The magnitude of the disaster is always unanticipated. During one of the seasons a cloudburst caused devastating floods and landslides leading to high casualties. There was major damage to infrastructure like roads, bridges and power generating units. This led to more than 100000 pilgrims, tourist and other locals trapped across different routes and locations. The people trapped in your area of responsibility includes senior citizens, patients in hospitals, women and children, hiker, tourist, ruling parties, regional presidents along with his family, additional chief secretary of the neighboring state, and prisoners in jail.
As a civil services officer of the state, what would be the order in which you would rescue these people and why? Give Justifications - 20 MarksView Answer
One of the scientists working in the R&D laboratory of a major pharmaceutical company discovers that one of the company’s bestselling veterinary drugs has the potential to cure a currently incurable liver disease which is prevalent in tribal areas. However, developing a variant of the drug suitable for human beings entailed a lot of research and development having a huge expenditure to the extent of Rs. 50 crores. It was unlikely that the company would recover the cost as the disease was rampant only in poverty-stricken areas having very little market otherwise.
If you were the CEO, then
(a) Identify the various actions that you could take
(b) Evaluate the pros and cons of each of your actions - 20 MarksView Answer
You are the Sarpanch of a Panchayat. There is a primary school run by the government in your area. Midday meals are provided to children attending the school. The headmaster has now appointed a new cook in the school to prepare the meals. However, when it is found that cook is from Dalit community, almost half of the children belonging to higher castes are not allowed to take meals by their parents. Consequentl,y the attendance in the schools falls sharply. This could result in the possibility of discontinuation of midday meal scheme, thereafter of teaching staff and subsequent closing down the school. (20 Marks) (250 Words)
(a) Discuss some feasible strategies to overcome the conflict and to createthe right ambiance.
(b) What should be the responsibilities of different social segments and agencies to create positive social ambiance for accepting such changes? - 20 MarksView Answer
A private company is known for its efficiency, transparency, and employee welfare. The company though owned by a private individual has a cooperative character where employees feel a sense of ownership. The company employs nearly 700 personnel and they have voluntarily decided not to form a union. One day suddenly in the morning, about 40 men belonging to the political party gate crashed into the factory demanding jobs in the factory. They threatened the management and employees and also used foul language. The employees feel demoralized. It was clear that those people who gate-crashed wanted to be on the payroll of the company as well as continue as volunteers/members of the party. The company maintains high standards of integrity and does not extend favors to civil administration which also includes law enforcement agencies. Such incidents occur in the public sector also.
(a) Assume you are the CEO of the company. What would you do to diffuse the volatile situation on the date of gate-crashing with the violent mob sitting inside the company premises?
(b) What can be the long-term solution to the issue discussed in the case?
(c) Every solution/action that you suggest will have a negative and a positive impact on you as (CEO), the employees, and the performance of the employees. Analyze the consequences of each of your suggested actions.
In just 60 sec
Evaluate your handwritten answer
- Get detailed feedback
- Model Answer after evaluation
Model Answers by Subject
Crack UPSC with your
Personal AI Mentor
An AI-powered ecosystem to learn, practice, and evaluate with discipline
