Score:
8.5/15
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
Topper’s Copy
GS2
Indian Polity
15 marks
“Recent legislative reforms indicate a shift towards greater foreign participation in strategic sectors.” In this context, examine the objectives of the SHANTI Bill, 2025 and the Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2025, and discuss their implications for India’s energy security and financial sector development.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Demand of the Question
- Examine objectives of the SHANTI Bill, 2025 and the Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2025
- Discuss implications for India's energy security from SHANTI Bill
- Discuss implications for financial sector development from Insurance Bill
- Context of greater foreign participation in strategic sectors
What you wrote:
To ensure ease of doing business, economic growth and strategic autonomy, recent legislative acts like SHANTI Bill 2025 allowing private participation in nuclear sector and Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill 2025 allowing 100% FDI in insurance sector indicate a shift towards greater foreign participation.
To ensure ease of doing business, economic growth and strategic autonomy, recent legislative acts like SHANTI Bill 2025 allowing private participation in nuclear sector and Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill 2025 allowing 100% FDI in insurance sector indicate a shift towards greater foreign participation.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could enhance with specific data (e.g., "India's nuclear capacity currently at 7 GW needs 14x expansion to meet 100 GW target by 2047" or "Insurance penetration at 4.2% compared to global average of 7.4%").
What you wrote:
Objectives of SHANTI Bill and Insurance Bill
SHANTI Bill
1) Nuclear capacity - mobilise private capital to achieve 100 GW by 2047.
2) Facilitate advanced nuclear technology transfer by resolving critical liability barriers.
3) Bypass carbon taxes through SMRs.
4) Strategic control over uranium enrichments, heavy water productions.
5) Regulation through statutory status to Atomic Energy Regulation Board.
Insurance Bill
1) FDI mobilisation through 100% FDI through automatic route in insurance sector.
2) Reinsurance entry-through cut limits for foreign insurers to ₹1000 crore.
3) Equity flexibility through IRDAI threshold for approval to 5%.
4) IRDAI empowerment through provisions of penalties.
5) Strengthen Insurance for All by 2047.
Objectives of SHANTI Bill and Insurance Bill
SHANTI Bill
1) Nuclear capacity - mobilise private capital to achieve 100 GW by 2047.
2) Facilitate advanced nuclear technology transfer by resolving critical liability barriers.
3) Bypass carbon taxes through SMRs.
4) Strategic control over uranium enrichments, heavy water productions.
5) Regulation through statutory status to Atomic Energy Regulation Board.
Insurance Bill
1) FDI mobilisation through 100% FDI through automatic route in insurance sector.
2) Reinsurance entry-through cut limits for foreign insurers to ₹1000 crore.
3) Equity flexibility through IRDAI threshold for approval to 5%.
4) IRDAI empowerment through provisions of penalties.
5) Strengthen Insurance for All by 2047.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could clarify technical provisions (e.g., "Minimum capital requirement reduced from ₹5000 crore to ₹1000 crore for foreign reinsurers to enter Indian market")
- Could explain current sector challenges these bills address (e.g., "Nuclear sector's 3% share in energy mix vs global average of 10%" or "Insurance density of $91 compared to global average of $790")
What you wrote:
[DRAWING:
A mind map with "Implications" in the center. Five branches extend from the center.
The first branch points to "Implications for India's energy security".
The second branch points to a list of five implications.
The third branch points to "Implications for Finance sector development".
The fourth branch points to another list of five implications.
The fifth branch points to "Way Forward".]
Implications for India's energy security
1) Energy security goal - enable the capacity to reach 100 GW by 2047 and net zero by 2070.
2) Nuclear tech hub - focus on indigenous nuclear energy ecosystem and innovation potential for regional hub status.
3) Narrower liability - capped limits to ₹100 - ₹3000 crore → risk of neglect of safety.
4) Weakened accountability due to no supplier's right to resist.
5) Privatisation of highly crucial sector → risk of business-crime nexus.
[DRAWING:
A mind map with "Implications" in the center. Five branches extend from the center.
The first branch points to "Implications for India's energy security".
The second branch points to a list of five implications.
The third branch points to "Implications for Finance sector development".
The fourth branch points to another list of five implications.
The fifth branch points to "Way Forward".]
Implications for India's energy security
1) Energy security goal - enable the capacity to reach 100 GW by 2047 and net zero by 2070.
2) Nuclear tech hub - focus on indigenous nuclear energy ecosystem and innovation potential for regional hub status.
3) Narrower liability - capped limits to ₹100 - ₹3000 crore → risk of neglect of safety.
4) Weakened accountability due to no supplier's right to resist.
5) Privatisation of highly crucial sector → risk of business-crime nexus.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could contextualize liability caps (e.g., "Fukushima disaster cost $200 billion while SHANTI caps at maximum ₹3000 crore, raising adequacy concerns")
- Could discuss energy security benefits (e.g., "Reducing coal import dependency of $50 billion annually through nuclear expansion")
What you wrote:
Implications for Finance sector development
1) Financial inclusion - increased penetration of insurance and reinsurance entities.
2) Stable FDI inflows rather than volatile FPI inflow.
3) Trust deficit against foreign entities → ↓ penetration.
4) Capital outflow risk - foreign entities might use profits in home country.
5) Elite and urban bias - neglect of rural and cooperative sector.
Way Forward
1) Composite licensing inspired by UK, Australia for better functioning.
2) Regulatory safeguards for IRDAI, AERB to ensure accountability of operators.
3) Security social audits for private operators.
4) Liability Fund management to reduce negative impacts of accidents.
Implications for Finance sector development
1) Financial inclusion - increased penetration of insurance and reinsurance entities.
2) Stable FDI inflows rather than volatile FPI inflow.
3) Trust deficit against foreign entities → ↓ penetration.
4) Capital outflow risk - foreign entities might use profits in home country.
5) Elite and urban bias - neglect of rural and cooperative sector.
Way Forward
1) Composite licensing inspired by UK, Australia for better functioning.
2) Regulatory safeguards for IRDAI, AERB to ensure accountability of operators.
3) Security social audits for private operators.
4) Liability Fund management to reduce negative impacts of accidents.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could strengthen with comparative data (e.g., "Foreign insurers' 47% market share in Singapore vs current 2% in India shows growth potential")
- Could elaborate on reinsurance benefits (e.g., "Enhanced catastrophe risk coverage crucial for climate-vulnerable economy with annual disaster losses of $10 billion")
What you wrote:
Way Forward
1) Composite licensing inspired by UK, Australia for better functioning.
2) Regulatory safeguards for IRDAI, AERB to ensure accountability of operators.
3) Security social audits for private operators.
4) Liability Fund management to reduce negative impacts of accidents.
Way Forward
1) Composite licensing inspired by UK, Australia for better functioning.
2) Regulatory safeguards for IRDAI, AERB to ensure accountability of operators.
3) Security social audits for private operators.
4) Liability Fund management to reduce negative impacts of accidents.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could specify implementation mechanisms (e.g., "Mandatory technology transfer clauses similar to defense procurement for nuclear partnerships")
- Could add monitoring frameworks (e.g., "Quarterly parliamentary oversight on foreign participation in strategic sectors")
What you wrote:
To ensure robust energy security and financial inclusion, strong safeguards and smart reforms remain crucial for India.
To ensure robust energy security and financial inclusion, strong safeguards and smart reforms remain crucial for India.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could strengthen with specific policy recommendations (e.g., "Establishing Strategic Sector Monitoring Authority to oversee foreign participation while ensuring national security priorities") or reference to successful models (e.g., "Following South Korea's approach of technology absorption with domestic capability building").
Strong structural organization with comprehensive coverage of both bills and balanced analysis of implications. The answer demonstrates good understanding of policy objectives and potential challenges. Minor improvements needed in providing specific data points and clearer technical explanations to enhance credibility and depth.
Demand of the Question
- Examine objectives of the SHANTI Bill, 2025 and the Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2025
- Discuss implications for India's energy security from SHANTI Bill
- Discuss implications for financial sector development from Insurance Bill
- Context of greater foreign participation in strategic sectors
What you wrote:
To ensure ease of doing business, economic growth and strategic autonomy, recent legislative acts like SHANTI Bill 2025 allowing private participation in nuclear sector and Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill 2025 allowing 100% FDI in insurance sector indicate a shift towards greater foreign participation.
To ensure ease of doing business, economic growth and strategic autonomy, recent legislative acts like SHANTI Bill 2025 allowing private participation in nuclear sector and Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill 2025 allowing 100% FDI in insurance sector indicate a shift towards greater foreign participation.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could enhance with specific data (e.g., "India's nuclear capacity currently at 7 GW needs 14x expansion to meet 100 GW target by 2047" or "Insurance penetration at 4.2% compared to global average of 7.4%").
More Challenges
View All- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
Yesterday
“Supplementary Demands for Grants are an important fiscal instrument for managing unforeseen expenditure.” In this context, examine the rationale behind additional allocations for fertilizer subsidy and compensation to oil marketing companies, and assess their implications for fiscal discipline and economic stability.
- View Challenge
GS2
SOCIAL_ISSUES_AND_SCHEMES
20 Dec, 2025
“The replacement of MGNREGA with the Viksit Bharat Guarantee for Rozgar and Ajeevika Mission (Gramin) Bill, 2025 marks a shift from a rights-based welfare framework to a budget-driven approach.” Critically examine the implications of this shift for rural employment security and fiscal federalism in India.
- View Challenge
GS2
International Relations
19 Dec, 2025
“The evolution of the U.S. National Security Strategy reflects a shift from partnership-based global leadership to conditional burden-sharing.” In this context, examine the implications of the 2025 U.S. National Security Strategy for India’s strategic autonomy and its role in the Indo-Pacific.
