Score:
9.5/15
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
Topper’s Copy
GS3
Environment & Ecology
15 marks
The 2024 India–Pakistan Smog highlights that air pollution in South Asia is a transboundary problem. Discuss the key causes of this crisis and suggest long-term regional strategies to tackle it.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Demand of the Question
- Discuss the key causes of the 2024 India-Pakistan Smog crisis.
- Suggest long-term regional strategies to tackle the air pollution problem in South Asia.
- Explain why air pollution in South Asia is a transboundary problem.
What you wrote:
Key Causes of the crisis:
Key Causes of the crisis:
Suggestions to improve:
- Could begin with a brief mention of the 2024 smog episode (e.g., severe smog engulfed Delhi and Lahore in November 2024, with AQI crossing 400, affecting over 50 million people and disrupting daily life, highlighting the transboundary nature of air pollution).
What you wrote:
① Agricultural Stubble Burning:
→ Punjab & Punjab follow identical rice-wheat cycles leading to synchronous residue burning.
→ Seasonal temperature inversion traps these pollutants.
① Agricultural Stubble Burning:
→ Punjab & Punjab follow identical rice-wheat cycles leading to synchronous residue burning.
→ Seasonal temperature inversion traps these pollutants.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can emphasize transboundary airflow (e.g., westerly winds during winter carry emissions from Punjab-Pakistan into Delhi-NCR, while easterlies push Delhi's pollution towards Lahore, creating a shared pollution dome).
- Could add data on emission sources (e.g., stubble burning contributes ~40% of PM2.5 during peak months as per SAFAR; vehicular emissions account for ~30% in urban centers).
What you wrote:
② Industrial & Vehicular Emissions:
→ Unregulated brick kiln, coal-based industries & rising vehicular density in Lahore, Delhi & adjoining cities worsen the air quality.
② Industrial & Vehicular Emissions:
→ Unregulated brick kiln, coal-based industries & rising vehicular density in Lahore, Delhi & adjoining cities worsen the air quality.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can emphasize transboundary airflow (e.g., westerly winds during winter carry emissions from Punjab-Pakistan into Delhi-NCR, while easterlies push Delhi's pollution towards Lahore, creating a shared pollution dome).
- Could add data on emission sources (e.g., stubble burning contributes ~40% of PM2.5 during peak months as per SAFAR; vehicular emissions account for ~30% in urban centers).
What you wrote:
③ Meteorological factors:
→ low wind speeds, winter inversion & geographical trapping within the Indo-Gangetic basin intensifying the smog layer.
③ Meteorological factors:
→ low wind speeds, winter inversion & geographical trapping within the Indo-Gangetic basin intensifying the smog layer.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can emphasize transboundary airflow (e.g., westerly winds during winter carry emissions from Punjab-Pakistan into Delhi-NCR, while easterlies push Delhi's pollution towards Lahore, creating a shared pollution dome).
- Could add data on emission sources (e.g., stubble burning contributes ~40% of PM2.5 during peak months as per SAFAR; vehicular emissions account for ~30% in urban centers).
What you wrote:
④ Urban Construction Dust:
→ Rapid urbanization with poor dust-control norms contributes heavily to PM2.5 & PM10 levels.
④ Urban Construction Dust:
→ Rapid urbanization with poor dust-control norms contributes heavily to PM2.5 & PM10 levels.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can emphasize transboundary airflow (e.g., westerly winds during winter carry emissions from Punjab-Pakistan into Delhi-NCR, while easterlies push Delhi's pollution towards Lahore, creating a shared pollution dome).
- Could add data on emission sources (e.g., stubble burning contributes ~40% of PM2.5 during peak months as per SAFAR; vehicular emissions account for ~30% in urban centers).
What you wrote:
⑤ Lack of coordinated monitoring:
→ Absence of a shared real-time air-quality data system between SAARC nations to provide early warning & joint action.
⑤ Lack of coordinated monitoring:
→ Absence of a shared real-time air-quality data system between SAARC nations to provide early warning & joint action.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can emphasize transboundary airflow (e.g., westerly winds during winter carry emissions from Punjab-Pakistan into Delhi-NCR, while easterlies push Delhi's pollution towards Lahore, creating a shared pollution dome).
- Could add data on emission sources (e.g., stubble burning contributes ~40% of PM2.5 during peak months as per SAFAR; vehicular emissions account for ~30% in urban centers).
What you wrote:
Long-Term Regional Strategies:
① A SAARC-level clean air framework:
→ Similar to the EU's cross-border emission Directives point standards for PM levels & industrial emissions.
② Transboundary early warning system:
→ shared satellite-based monitoring & joint forecasting through IMB-PMD collaboration.
③ Agricultural Transition Package:
→ Regional fund for crop diversification machinery subsidies & bio-economy utilization of stubble.
④ Unified Emission Standards:
→ Harmonised norms for vehicles, brick kilns, & thermal plants across borders.
⑤ Seasonal Action Plans:
→ Coordinated winter action protocol, including restrictions on construction & movement of high-emitting vehicles.
Long-Term Regional Strategies:
① A SAARC-level clean air framework:
→ Similar to the EU's cross-border emission Directives point standards for PM levels & industrial emissions.
② Transboundary early warning system:
→ shared satellite-based monitoring & joint forecasting through IMB-PMD collaboration.
③ Agricultural Transition Package:
→ Regional fund for crop diversification machinery subsidies & bio-economy utilization of stubble.
④ Unified Emission Standards:
→ Harmonised norms for vehicles, brick kilns, & thermal plants across borders.
⑤ Seasonal Action Plans:
→ Coordinated winter action protocol, including restrictions on construction & movement of high-emitting vehicles.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could propose institutional mechanisms (e.g., revival of SAARC Environment Ministers' Forum or creation of a South Asia Clean Air Alliance under UNEP patronage).
- Can include examples like Malé Declaration on Control and Prevention of Air Pollution as a ready platform for regional cooperation.
- Could add community-level measures (e.g., awareness campaigns, citizen science air-quality monitoring networks involving Indo-Pak border communities).
What you wrote:
The India-Pakistan smog crisis highlights that air pollution is not an isolated national issue but a regional public-goods challenge. Only sustained, cooperative & science-based regional action can ensure cleaner cities in South Asia.
The India-Pakistan smog crisis highlights that air pollution is not an isolated national issue but a regional public-goods challenge. Only sustained, cooperative & science-based regional action can ensure cleaner cities in South Asia.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could link it to sustainable development (e.g., regional air-quality action aligns with SDG 3 (Good Health) and SDG 13 (Climate Action), ensuring healthier, climate-resilient South Asia).
The answer is well-structured with strong causes and strategies but misses the transboundary explanation explicitly and lacks institutional/data depth. Adding cross-border airflow dynamics, examples of cooperation frameworks, and specific institutional mechanisms would significantly strengthen it.
Demand of the Question
- Discuss the key causes of the 2024 India-Pakistan Smog crisis.
- Suggest long-term regional strategies to tackle the air pollution problem in South Asia.
- Explain why air pollution in South Asia is a transboundary problem.
What you wrote:
Key Causes of the crisis:
Key Causes of the crisis:
Suggestions to improve:
- Could begin with a brief mention of the 2024 smog episode (e.g., severe smog engulfed Delhi and Lahore in November 2024, with AQI crossing 400, affecting over 50 million people and disrupting daily life, highlighting the transboundary nature of air pollution).
More Challenges
View All- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
29 Nov, 2025
Critically examine the Election Commission’s stance on simultaneous elections in India, especially with reference to the basic structure doctrine and election-related institutional mechanisms.
- View Challenge
GS2
Governance
Yesterday
Critically examine the limitations of the POSH Act in addressing sexual harassment in educational institutions, especially in cases involving power imbalance and emotional manipulation. Suggest reforms.
- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
27 Nov, 2025
With the rise of deepfake technologies and AI-generated content, discuss the challenges they pose to personality rights in India. Evaluate the adequacy of existing legal frameworks and suggest measures to ensure stronger protection.
