Model Answer

GS3

Environment & Ecology

10 marks

“The SHANTI Bill marks a paradigm shift in India’s nuclear power governance by addressing long-standing regulatory and liability bottlenecks.”
Critically examine how the SHANTI Bill seeks to balance energy security, safety, and global integration in India’s nuclear power programme.

Despite possessing significant technical expertise and long-term strategic vision, India’s nuclear power programme has remained underutilised, contributing a modest share to the overall energy mix. A key reason has been a complex and globally misaligned legal–liability regime that discouraged private and international participation. The Sustainable Harnessing and Advancement of Nuclear Energy for Transforming India (SHANTI) Bill seeks to address these structural constraints and reposition nuclear energy as a reliable pillar of India’s clean energy transition.

Balancing Energy Security

The SHANTI Bill explicitly links nuclear power with India’s long-term energy security and decarbonisation goals. By setting an ambitious target of 100 GW of nuclear capacity by 2047, it recognises nuclear energy as a stable, low-carbon baseload source that can complement intermittent renewables such as solar and wind. The bill opens the sector to both public and private domestic players, thereby expanding investment capacity, accelerating project execution, and reducing overdependence on coal. At the same time, by excluding foreign companies as licensees, it seeks to preserve strategic autonomy and sovereignty over critical energy infrastructure.

Strengthening Safety and Liability Architecture

A major reform under the SHANTI Bill lies in rationalising nuclear liability and safety regulation. By replacing the Atomic Energy Act, 1962 and the Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act, 2010 with a unified legal framework, the bill reduces regulatory fragmentation. Operator liability is capped at 300 million Special Drawing Rights (SDR), in line with international conventions, while additional compensation is ensured through a Nuclear Liability Fund, providing financial certainty without diluting victim protection.

The bill also broadens the definition of nuclear damage and introduces a streamlined claims process, ensuring faster and more predictable compensation. Importantly, it recognises terrorism as a sovereign risk, placing responsibility on the central government for damages arising from such acts. Safety oversight is retained with the state through a strengthened Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB), reinforcing regulatory independence and public confidence.

Facilitating Global Integration

The SHANTI Bill aims to integrate India into the global nuclear mainstream by aligning liability, compensation, and regulatory norms with international best practices. This alignment enhances India’s credibility as a nuclear commerce partner and facilitates collaboration with technologically advanced countries, particularly the United States. The introduction of a special inventions and patent regime for nuclear-related technologies enables Indian firms to participate more actively in global nuclear supply chains, moving beyond reactor operation to high-value manufacturing and innovation.

Conclusion

While the SHANTI Bill is a bold and pragmatic reform, its success will depend on effective implementation, regulatory capacity of the AERB, and sustained public trust in nuclear safety. Concerns regarding exclusion of foreign licensees and environmental safeguards will require careful policy calibration. Nevertheless, by balancing energy security, safety, and global integration, the SHANTI Bill represents a decisive step toward transforming nuclear power from a theoretical option into a practical and reliable component of India’s clean energy future.

More Challenges

View All
  • GS3

    Science & Technology

    1 Mar, 2026

    Carbon Capture and Utilisation (CCU) is emerging as a key strategy for decarbonising hard-to-abate sectors in India. Explain the concept of CCU and examine its potential, challenges, and policy measures required for its large-scale adoption in India.

    View Challenge
  • GS3

    Indian Polity

    Yesterday

    “Recent advances in HIV treatment have focused on targeting the viral capsid using long-acting drugs such as lenacapavir.”
    Explain the significance of capsid-targeting therapies in controlling HIV infection. Also discuss the challenges of drug resistance and the role of combination therapy.

    View Challenge
  • GS2

    Indian Polity

    27 Feb, 2026

    The balance between transparency and privacy is a recurring constitutional challenge in India.
    In the light of recent amendments to the RTI framework through the Digital Personal Data Protection law, examine whether the exemption of personal information undermines accountability of public authorities.

    View Challenge

Master Answer Writingfor UPSC Mains

Join thousands of aspirants mastering answer writing with daily challenges, instant AI evaluation, and topper copies

View Today's Challenge
SuperKalam is your personal mentor for UPSC preparation, guiding you at every step of the exam journey.

Download the App

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Follow us

ⓒ Snapstack Technologies Private Limited