Score:
9/15
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
Topper’s Copy
GS2
International Relations
15 marks
"Critical minerals have emerged as the new strategic resources of the 21st century." Discuss their significance for India's economic and strategic security. Examine how international partnerships can strengthen India's critical mineral ecosystem.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Demand of the Question
- Significance of critical minerals for India's economic security
- Significance of critical minerals for India's strategic security
- Role of international partnerships in strengthening India's critical mineral ecosystem
- Discussion of challenges/issues (implied for comprehensive coverage)
What you wrote:
Critical minerals called the "new oil" of 21st century are vital for economic development & strategic security face high supply risk, need global partnership.
[DRAWING: A central box labeled "India's 30 critical minerals" has lines pointing outwards to various minerals: "lithium", "cobalt", "gallium", "copper", "titanium", "germanium", and "graphite". An arrow from the central box points to an oval labeled "Essential", which then has arrows pointing to different sectors: "renewable", "manufacturing", "AI", "semiconductor", and "defence".]
Critical minerals called the "new oil" of 21st century are vital for economic development & strategic security face high supply risk, need global partnership.
[DRAWING: A central box labeled "India's 30 critical minerals" has lines pointing outwards to various minerals: "lithium", "cobalt", "gallium", "copper", "titanium", "germanium", and "graphite". An arrow from the central box points to an oval labeled "Essential", which then has arrows pointing to different sectors: "renewable", "manufacturing", "AI", "semiconductor", and "defence".]
Suggestions to improve:
- Could enhance with specific context (e.g., "India imports over 95% of lithium and cobalt requirements, making supply chain diversification critical for economic resilience")
What you wrote:
Significance
A. Economic security:
1) Guard from external supply chain disruption
eg 85% REE monopoly by China
2) Ensure indigenisation of market & services
eg #Make in India & AtmaNirbhar Bharat
3) Safeguard manufacturing & industrialization
eg Lithium for solar cells.
4) Seamless energy transition - renewable-focused "2070 Net zero"
eg Cobalt, Nickel ⇒ renewable catalysts
5) Ensure active investment and employment opportunities.
eg Critical minerals dependent automobile sectors
Significance
A. Economic security:
1) Guard from external supply chain disruption
eg 85% REE monopoly by China
2) Ensure indigenisation of market & services
eg #Make in India & AtmaNirbhar Bharat
3) Safeguard manufacturing & industrialization
eg Lithium for solar cells.
4) Seamless energy transition - renewable-focused "2070 Net zero"
eg Cobalt, Nickel ⇒ renewable catalysts
5) Ensure active investment and employment opportunities.
eg Critical minerals dependent automobile sectors
Suggestions to improve:
- Could strengthen with economic data (e.g., "Critical mineral processing industry can contribute **$55 billion to GDP by 2030** as per NITI Aayog estimates")
- Could elaborate on sectoral impact (e.g., "Lithium shortage could delay India's **500 GW renewable capacity target by 2030**, affecting $20 billion in planned investments")
What you wrote:
B. Strategic security
1) Defence indigenisation - Gallium, Lanthanum core for weapons
eg Reduce import-dependence ⇒ in Top-3 defence importers (SIPRI)
2) Enhance strategic autonomy - leverage geopolitical independency
eg China's block on REE supply in 2025
3) Lead in technological advancements
eg iPhone plant in Hyderabad
4) Leverage "mineral diplomacy" - secures dual role ⇒ domestic security and external resilience
eg Resource diplomacy in Africa, Central Asia
B. Strategic security
1) Defence indigenisation - Gallium, Lanthanum core for weapons
eg Reduce import-dependence ⇒ in Top-3 defence importers (SIPRI)
2) Enhance strategic autonomy - leverage geopolitical independency
eg China's block on REE supply in 2025
3) Lead in technological advancements
eg iPhone plant in Hyderabad
4) Leverage "mineral diplomacy" - secures dual role ⇒ domestic security and external resilience
eg Resource diplomacy in Africa, Central Asia
Suggestions to improve:
- Could add technological dimension (e.g., "Germanium and Gallium are essential for **semiconductor manufacturing under PLI scheme**, reducing dependence on Taiwan and South Korea")
- Could strengthen with space and nuclear applications (e.g., "Rare earth elements critical for **ISRO's satellite programs and nuclear reactor components**")
What you wrote:
Issues
[DRAWING: A central circle labeled "Issues" with four arrows pointing to specific points: "> 85% mineral import from China (MOSPI)", "Poor advance-drilling tech", "Ranks 3rd in REE reserves but output < 1% - resource paradox", and "[Weak recycling] + [Global supply chain vulnerabilities]"]
Issues
[DRAWING: A central circle labeled "Issues" with four arrows pointing to specific points: "> 85% mineral import from China (MOSPI)", "Poor advance-drilling tech", "Ranks 3rd in REE reserves but output < 1% - resource paradox", and "[Weak recycling] + [Global supply chain vulnerabilities]"]
Suggestions to improve:
- Could expand on regulatory challenges (e.g., "**MMDR Act amendments needed for faster clearances** - current approval process takes 3-5 years vs 6 months in Australia")
- Could add environmental dimension (e.g., "Mining operations face **tribal displacement issues in Odisha's bauxite belt**, requiring sustainable extraction models")
What you wrote:
International partnership to strengthen:
1) Global handshakes eg MSP in 2023.
2) Collaboration & cooperation
eg KABIL deal in Li → Chile / Argentina
3) Shared grouping reduces vulnerabilities
eg India - USA - Australia deal
4) Investment-oriented diplomacy
eg {Africa > 70% untapped resources} + {India's line of credit} → {shared growth}
5) Other
[DRAWING: A pie chart divided into three segments: "Strategic stockpile", "PPP", and "Diversity". To the right of the chart is "+" followed by a flow diagram: "Recycle" pointing down to "Reuse", and "Resupply" pointing up to "Recycle". To the right of this is another "+" and a bracketed list: "Tech upgrade"]
International partnership to strengthen:
1) Global handshakes eg MSP in 2023.
2) Collaboration & cooperation
eg KABIL deal in Li → Chile / Argentina
3) Shared grouping reduces vulnerabilities
eg India - USA - Australia deal
4) Investment-oriented diplomacy
eg {Africa > 70% untapped resources} + {India's line of credit} → {shared growth}
5) Other
[DRAWING: A pie chart divided into three segments: "Strategic stockpile", "PPP", and "Diversity". To the right of the chart is "+" followed by a flow diagram: "Recycle" pointing down to "Reuse", and "Resupply" pointing up to "Recycle". To the right of this is another "+" and a bracketed list: "Tech upgrade"]
Suggestions to improve:
- Could elaborate on multilateral frameworks (e.g., "**Minerals Security Partnership with 14 countries** aims to diversify supply chains away from Chinese dominance")
- Could add technology transfer dimension (e.g., "Australia-India partnership includes **lithium processing technology transfer** under $5.8 billion trade agreement")
What you wrote:
Thus, India's National critical mission, MMDR Act and KABIL-led partnership essential to build self-reliant & resilient Bharat.
Thus, India's National critical mission, MMDR Act and KABIL-led partnership essential to build self-reliant & resilient Bharat.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could strengthen with timeline and targets (e.g., "Achieving **50% import substitution by 2030** through strategic partnerships will be crucial for India's transition to clean energy economy")
Strong structural approach with effective use of diagrams to illustrate complex relationships. Good integration of economic and strategic dimensions with relevant examples. However, some claims need stronger quantitative backing and recent policy developments could be better incorporated.
Demand of the Question
- Significance of critical minerals for India's economic security
- Significance of critical minerals for India's strategic security
- Role of international partnerships in strengthening India's critical mineral ecosystem
- Discussion of challenges/issues (implied for comprehensive coverage)
What you wrote:
Critical minerals called the "new oil" of 21st century are vital for economic development & strategic security face high supply risk, need global partnership.
[DRAWING: A central box labeled "India's 30 critical minerals" has lines pointing outwards to various minerals: "lithium", "cobalt", "gallium", "copper", "titanium", "germanium", and "graphite". An arrow from the central box points to an oval labeled "Essential", which then has arrows pointing to different sectors: "renewable", "manufacturing", "AI", "semiconductor", and "defence".]
Critical minerals called the "new oil" of 21st century are vital for economic development & strategic security face high supply risk, need global partnership.
[DRAWING: A central box labeled "India's 30 critical minerals" has lines pointing outwards to various minerals: "lithium", "cobalt", "gallium", "copper", "titanium", "germanium", and "graphite". An arrow from the central box points to an oval labeled "Essential", which then has arrows pointing to different sectors: "renewable", "manufacturing", "AI", "semiconductor", and "defence".]
Suggestions to improve:
- Could enhance with specific context (e.g., "India imports over 95% of lithium and cobalt requirements, making supply chain diversification critical for economic resilience")
More Challenges
View All- View Challenge
GS3
Environment & Ecology
9 Oct, 2026
The Living Planet Report highlights a sharp decline in wildlife populations worldwide. What does this decline actually indicate? Discuss the major causes of biodiversity loss and suggest conservation measures.
- View Challenge
GS3
Economy
Yesterday
How does a repo rate hike help control inflation? Discuss its impact on the Indian economy.
- View Challenge
GS1
Physical Geography
7 Oct, 2026
Rapid urbanisation is intensifying the Urban Heat Island effect in Indian cities. Examine how urban planning contributes to rising heat stress and suggest measures to build heat-resilient cities.
SuperKalam is your personal mentor for UPSC preparation, guiding you at every step of the exam journey.
Download the App
STUDY RESOURCES
CONTACT US
ⓒ Snapstack Technologies Private Limited