Score:
5.5/10
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
Topper’s Copy
GS2
Governance
10 marks
Discuss how Karnataka’s decision to grant paid menstrual leave to women employees contributes to gender equity in the workplace. Highlight the potential benefits and challenges associated with implementing such policies.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Demand of the Question
- Discuss Karnataka's menstrual leave policy's contribution to gender equity
- Highlight potential benefits of such policies
- Highlight challenges in implementation
- Overall assessment of workplace gender equity impact
What you wrote:
Women's participation in the workforce is increasing. It becomes essential to enact a law or policy that ensures the dignity and gender equity. Karnataka has become the first state to grant paid menstrual leave to women employees of both the Sectors (public & private).
Women's participation in the workforce is increasing. It becomes essential to enact a law or policy that ensures the dignity and gender equity. Karnataka has become the first state to grant paid menstrual leave to women employees of both the Sectors (public & private).
Suggestions to improve:
- Could define gender equity in workplace context (e.g., equal opportunities, fair treatment regardless of biological differences)
- Can reference constitutional provisions like Article 15(3) which allows special provisions for women
What you wrote:
[DRAWING: A mind map with 'Key Features of the policy' at its center. An arrow points from 'Objective: To promote gender-equity & employee welfare' to the center. Arrows point from the center to four other points: 'Aligns with DPSP (A-42) "Just and humane conditions of work"', 'Paid leave of 1 day per month (12 days annually)', 'Implemented with Department of women and child development', and 'Coverage: Applicable to women in both public and organised private sectors'.]
[DRAWING: A mind map with 'Key Features of the policy' at its center. An arrow points from 'Objective: To promote gender-equity & employee welfare' to the center. Arrows point from the center to four other points: 'Aligns with DPSP (A-42) "Just and humane conditions of work"', 'Paid leave of 1 day per month (12 days annually)', 'Implemented with Department of women and child development', and 'Coverage: Applicable to women in both public and organised private sectors'.]
Suggestions to improve:
- Could add coverage limitations (e.g., 85% of women work in unorganized sector remain excluded)
What you wrote:
Significance & Benefits:
(i) Gender-Equity: Reinforces women's right to health and dignity at the workplace.
(ii) Ensures productivity: Benefits for women, will motivate them to work efficiently & productively.
(iii) Remove fear of menstruation taboos- Normalizes menstruation as a legitimate health concern, breaking taboos and encouraging dialogue on women's right to work.
(iv) Boosts Morale & Ethics - Women may feel valued, leading to higher job satisfaction & reduced turnover.
(v) Increase in Women labour force participation - Women in urban areas have less participation in workforce than rural (80%), due to fear & problems related to healthcare and monthly challenges.
- It will ensure women's physiological needs.
Significance & Benefits:
(i) Gender-Equity: Reinforces women's right to health and dignity at the workplace.
(ii) Ensures productivity: Benefits for women, will motivate them to work efficiently & productively.
(iii) Remove fear of menstruation taboos- Normalizes menstruation as a legitimate health concern, breaking taboos and encouraging dialogue on women's right to work.
(iv) Boosts Morale & Ethics - Women may feel valued, leading to higher job satisfaction & reduced turnover.
(v) Increase in Women labour force participation - Women in urban areas have less participation in workforce than rural (80%), due to fear & problems related to healthcare and monthly challenges.
- It will ensure women's physiological needs.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could include specific data (e.g., women's workforce participation dropped from 36% in 2005 to 23% in 2018 due to various barriers)
- Can mention economic benefits (e.g., reduced absenteeism costs companies ₹3,000 crores annually according to studies)
What you wrote:
Challenges:
(i) Workplace bias: Risks of reinforcing stereotypes like women are less capable or need "special treatment".
(ii) Implementation issues - Difficulties in monitoring leave usage.
(iii) Privacy of personal details - May hesitate to avail such leave due to fear of judgement or insecurity.
(iv) Authentication - Whether the leave is authentic or misused.
Challenges:
(i) Workplace bias: Risks of reinforcing stereotypes like women are less capable or need "special treatment".
(ii) Implementation issues - Difficulties in monitoring leave usage.
(iii) Privacy of personal details - May hesitate to avail such leave due to fear of judgement or insecurity.
(iv) Authentication - Whether the leave is authentic or misused.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could discuss employer concerns (e.g., additional cost burden of ₹500-1000 per employee annually)
- Can mention potential discrimination in hiring (employers might prefer male candidates to avoid leave costs)
What you wrote:
The step taken by Karnataka government will be marked as a landmark in overcoming the stigma among women and to problems related to menstruation.
The step taken by Karnataka government will be marked as a landmark in overcoming the stigma among women and to problems related to menstruation.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could connect to Article 21 (Right to Life with Dignity) and constitutional goal of substantive equality
- Can reference successful international examples (e.g., Japan's menstrual leave since 1947 showing long-term positive outcomes)
Your answer demonstrates good understanding of the policy's significance and provides balanced analysis of benefits and challenges. The mind map effectively organizes key information, though some statistical claims need verification and the scope could be expanded to include broader implementation concerns.
Demand of the Question
- Discuss Karnataka's menstrual leave policy's contribution to gender equity
- Highlight potential benefits of such policies
- Highlight challenges in implementation
- Overall assessment of workplace gender equity impact
What you wrote:
Women's participation in the workforce is increasing. It becomes essential to enact a law or policy that ensures the dignity and gender equity. Karnataka has become the first state to grant paid menstrual leave to women employees of both the Sectors (public & private).
Women's participation in the workforce is increasing. It becomes essential to enact a law or policy that ensures the dignity and gender equity. Karnataka has become the first state to grant paid menstrual leave to women employees of both the Sectors (public & private).
Suggestions to improve:
- Could define gender equity in workplace context (e.g., equal opportunities, fair treatment regardless of biological differences)
- Can reference constitutional provisions like Article 15(3) which allows special provisions for women
More Challenges
View All- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
29 Nov, 2025
Critically examine the Election Commission’s stance on simultaneous elections in India, especially with reference to the basic structure doctrine and election-related institutional mechanisms.
- View Challenge
GS2
Governance
Yesterday
Critically examine the limitations of the POSH Act in addressing sexual harassment in educational institutions, especially in cases involving power imbalance and emotional manipulation. Suggest reforms.
- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
27 Nov, 2025
With the rise of deepfake technologies and AI-generated content, discuss the challenges they pose to personality rights in India. Evaluate the adequacy of existing legal frameworks and suggest measures to ensure stronger protection.
