Discuss the merits and demerits of the four ‘Labour Codes’ in the context of labour market reforms in India. What has been the progress so far in these regards?

GS 3
Economy
2024
15 Marks

Subject: Economy

The recent consolidation of 29 central labour laws into four Labour Codes marks a significant milestone in India's labour market reforms, aiming to balance worker welfare with ease of doing business.

Merits

  • Simplification & certainty: 29 central laws compressed into four, cutting ~1,200 sections to 480 and easing compliance for 63 million enterprises.
  • Ease of doing business: Single registration, single annual return, five-year licence and algorithm-based inspections curb “inspector-raj.”
  • Universal wage floor prevents any state from setting minimum wages below a centrally fixed level, aiding informal and farm workers.
  • Wider social security: Gig and platform workers to receive provident-fund, health and accident cover via a central fund.
  • Flexibility with safeguards: Lay-off threshold raised from 100 to 300 employees while mandating a reskilling fund for retrenched staff.
  • Gender & safety focus: Crèches for establishments with ≥50 workers, night-shift safeguards for women, and mandatory safety gear for contract labour.

Demerits

  • Job security dilution from higher lay-off threshold and easier fixed-term contracts.
  • Strikes harder: 14-day notice, 60-day cooling-off and, in some cases, 75% support required.
  • Vague gig-worker coverage: Contribution rates and benefit design left to future rules.
  • Broad delegated legislation risks divergent state standards.
  • Inspector-facilitator dual role may soften enforcement.
  • Unpaid care work excluded, overlooking a large share of women’s labour.

Progress So Far

  1. Rule-making: Centre finalised rules, but still all states yet to notified theirs, causing uneven readiness.
  2. Digital infrastructure: Shram Suvidha 2.0 for unified registration piloted; National Database for Unorganised Workers tops 290 million entries.
  3. Timeline: Phased enforcement now eyed for Q4 FY 2025-26, beginning with the Wage Code.
  4. Industry preparedness: Large firms have adjusted pay structures for the new “wage” definition; MSMEs seek clarity on overtime and penalties.
  5. Stakeholder pushback: Ten central trade unions plan a convention and possible strike; some states explore independent gig-worker boards.

The success of four codes hinges on uniform rule notification, effective tripartite oversight and swift activation of gig-worker funds and digital inspection systems; until then, the reforms remain legislated but not lived.

Answer Length

Model answers may exceed the word limit for better clarity and depth. Use them as a guide, but always frame your final answer within the exam’s prescribed limit.

In just 60 sec

Evaluate your handwritten answer

  • Get detailed feedback
  • Model Answer after evaluation
Evaluate Now

Crack UPSC with your
Personal AI Mentor

An AI-powered ecosystem to learn, practice, and evaluate with discipline

Start Now
SuperKalam is your personal mentor for UPSC preparation, guiding you at every step of the exam journey.
Follow us

ⓒ Snapstack Technologies Private Limited