Did the Government of India Act, of
1935 lay down a federal constitution?
Discuss.
Did the Government of India Act, of
1935 lay down a federal constitution?
Discuss.
The Government of India Act 1935 attempted to establish a federal structure but created a quasi-federal system with significant limitations rather than true federalism.
Federal Features Introduced
- Division of Powers: Established three lists - Federal List (59 subjects), Provincial List (54 subjects), and Concurrent List (36 subjects)
- Provincial Autonomy: Provinces gained self-governance in specified areas with elected ministries
- Bicameral Federal Legislature: Created Council of States (upper house) and Federal Assembly (lower house)
- Federal Court: Established to resolve Centre-Province disputes and constitutional matters
- Integration Framework: Envisaged union of British India and Princely States into single federation
Non-Federal/Unitary Elements
- Governor-General's Powers:
- Special Responsibilities in minorities, financial stability, civil services
- Emergency Powers to dismiss provincial governments
- Veto Power over federal and provincial legislation
- Provincial Limitations:
- Governors could override provincial ministers
- Reserved Subjects like police remained under British control
- ICS Officers answerable to central authority, not provinces
- Financial Control: Centre controlled provincial borrowing and major revenue sources
Why Federation Failed
| Aspect | Failure Reason |
|---|---|
| Princely States | Only 14 out of 565 states agreed to join |
| Political Opposition | Congress rejected discriminatory provisions |
| Implementation | World War II (1939) halted federal provisions |
| Autonomy Issues | Excessive safeguards limited genuine self-rule |
Assessment and Legacy
The Act established "federation with a strong centre" - federal in structure but unitary in spirit. Constitutional expert K.C. Wheare termed it "quasi-federal." Despite limitations, it influenced India's Constitution through the three-list system, federal court concept, and provincial autonomy principles.
The 1935 Act represented British compromise between Indian demands for self-rule and imperial control requirements, creating incomplete federalism that ultimately required complete overhaul post-independence.
Answer Length
Model answers may exceed the word limit for better clarity and depth. Use them as a guide, but always frame your final answer within the exam’s prescribed limit.
Indian Polity PYQs from 2016
- 12.5 MarksView Answer
What is the quasi-judicial body? Explain
with the help of concrete examples. - 12.5 MarksView Answer
What was held in the Coelho case? In
this context, can you say that judicial
review is of key importance amongst
the basic features of the Constitution? - 12.5 MarksView Answer
Discuss each adjective attached to the
word ‘Republic’ in the ‘Preamble’. Are
they defendable in the present
circumstances? - 12.5 MarksView Answer
Exercise of CAG’s powers in relation
to the accounts of the Union and the
States is derived from Article 149 of
the Indian Constitution. Discuss
whether an audit of the Government’s
policy implementation could amount
to overstepping its own (CAG)
jurisdiction. - 12.5 MarksView Answer
The Indian party system is passing
through a phase of transition which
looks to be full of contradictions and
paradoxes. Discuss. - 12.5 MarksView Answer
To what extent is Article 370 of the
Indian Constitution, bearing marginal
note “temporary provision with respect
to the State of Jammu and Kashmir”,
temporary? Discuss the future
prospects of this provision in the
context of Indian polity.
In just 60 sec
Evaluate your handwritten answer
- Get detailed feedback
- Model Answer after evaluation
Model Answers by Subject
Crack UPSC with your
Personal AI Mentor
An AI-powered ecosystem to learn, practice, and evaluate with discipline
