Score:
8/15
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
GS2
Indian Polity
15 marks
“The Anti-Defection Law, while aimed at ensuring political stability, has often been criticized for undermining intra-party democracy.”
In the light of recent political developments involving mass defections and mergers, critically examine the effectiveness of the Anti-Defection Law.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
The Anti-Defection law enshrined in the Tenth Schedule of the constitution (1985), was introduced to curb political instability caused by legislators switching parties for personal gains - colloquially called "Aaya Ram Gaya Ram" politics.
The Anti-Defection law enshrined in the Tenth Schedule of the constitution (1985), was introduced to curb political instability caused by legislators switching parties for personal gains - colloquially called "Aaya Ram Gaya Ram" politics.
Effectiveness of the law: - prevent horse-trading - legislators cannot defect individually for money or ministerial post. - ensures party discipline and stable governments. - Reduce party discipline and stable government. - Reduce political corruption at individual legislator level. - successfully deterred individual defections since 1985.
Effectiveness of the law: - prevent horse-trading - legislators cannot defect individually for money or ministerial post. - ensures party discipline and stable governments. - Reduce party discipline and stable government. - Reduce political corruption at individual legislator level. - successfully deterred individual defections since 1985.
Limitation and criticisms: (1) loophole of Mergers: → Allows defection if 2/3rd of party members agree - misused for engineered splits. → Recent example: Maharashtra (2022), Manipur, Goa, and Recently of Raghave chadda case. (2) undermine Intra-party Democracy: → legislators cannot vote against party even on matters of conscience. → MPs become rubber stamps of party leadership. (3) speaker's Bias: → Disqualification decided by speaker who belongs to ruling party - lack of neutrality. → case pending for years without decision. (4) mass Defections still happen: → law failed to prevent bulk defections disguised as mergers.
Limitation and criticisms: (1) loophole of Mergers: → Allows defection if 2/3rd of party members agree - misused for engineered splits. → Recent example: Maharashtra (2022), Manipur, Goa, and Recently of Raghave chadda case. (2) undermine Intra-party Democracy: → legislators cannot vote against party even on matters of conscience. → MPs become rubber stamps of party leadership. (3) speaker's Bias: → Disqualification decided by speaker who belongs to ruling party - lack of neutrality. → case pending for years without decision. (4) mass Defections still happen: → law failed to prevent bulk defections disguised as mergers.
Way forward: - Transfer disqualification power to Independent tribunal. - Fix time limit for speaker's decision (Supreme court suggest 3 months). - Distinguish between policy votes and confidence votes. Therefore, The anti-defection law needs urgent reform to balance party discipline with legislative independence and true democratic representation.
Way forward: - Transfer disqualification power to Independent tribunal. - Fix time limit for speaker's decision (Supreme court suggest 3 months). - Distinguish between policy votes and confidence votes. Therefore, The anti-defection law needs urgent reform to balance party discipline with legislative independence and true democratic representation.
Your answer demonstrates solid understanding of the Anti-Defection Law's framework and current challenges. The structure is logical, but the analysis needs deeper constitutional grounding and more specific recent examples to fully address the question's demands about mass defections and democratic implications.
The Anti-Defection law enshrined in the Tenth Schedule of the constitution (1985), was introduced to curb political instability caused by legislators switching parties for personal gains - colloquially called "Aaya Ram Gaya Ram" politics.
The Anti-Defection law enshrined in the Tenth Schedule of the constitution (1985), was introduced to curb political instability caused by legislators switching parties for personal gains - colloquially called "Aaya Ram Gaya Ram" politics.
GS3
Disaster Management
22 Nov, 2026
What are the causes of landslides in the Western Ghats? Discuss the role of early warning systems in landslide risk reduction.
GS2
Governance
Yesterday
What are the major risks associated with using Generative AI in governance? Suggest measures to ensure accuracy, transparency and accountability in its use.
GS3
Economy
20 Nov, 2026
What are the major challenges facing India's power sector? Suggest measures to ensure reliable and affordable electricity supply.