Score:
5/10
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
Topper’s Copy
GS2
International Relations
10 marks
"The recurring Afghanistan–Pakistan crisis has implications far beyond their bilateral relationship." Examine its impact on India's security and strategic interests.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Demand of the Question
- Examine impact on India's security interests
- Examine impact on India's strategic interests
- Show how Afghanistan-Pakistan crisis extends beyond bilateral scope
- Connect regional instability to India's broader concerns
What you wrote:
The Afghanistan - Pakistan relationship has remained volatile due to issues like border disputes (DURAND), cross-border terrorism, and the role of militant groups. This instability has consequences that extend beyond the two countries and significantly affect India's security and strategic environment.
The Afghanistan - Pakistan relationship has remained volatile due to issues like border disputes (DURAND), cross-border terrorism, and the role of militant groups. This instability has consequences that extend beyond the two countries and significantly affect India's security and strategic environment.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can begin with recent context like "The Taliban's return to power in 2021 has intensified the Afghanistan-Pakistan crisis, creating new security challenges for regional stability"
- Could briefly mention India's strategic stakes in the region to set up the analysis
What you wrote:
Impact on India's Security:
1) Cross border terrorism:
Instability in Afghanistan provides space for groups like Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) and others. Pakistan's internal security challenges often lead to diversion or support of extremist elements, indirectly affecting India through regional terror networks.
2) Safe havens for Anti-India groups:
Weak Afghan governance may allow groups like Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) and Jaish-e-Mohammed (JeM) to find indirect support or operational space via regional linkages.
3) Radicalisation and Ideological spillover:
Prolonged conflict strengthens extremist narratives, influencing youth radicalisation in South Asia, including parts of India.
Impact on India's Security:
1) Cross border terrorism:
Instability in Afghanistan provides space for groups like Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) and others. Pakistan's internal security challenges often lead to diversion or support of extremist elements, indirectly affecting India through regional terror networks.
2) Safe havens for Anti-India groups:
Weak Afghan governance may allow groups like Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) and Jaish-e-Mohammed (JeM) to find indirect support or operational space via regional linkages.
3) Radicalisation and Ideological spillover:
Prolonged conflict strengthens extremist narratives, influencing youth radicalisation in South Asia, including parts of India.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can include specific examples like "The **2008 Mumbai attacks** demonstrated how Pakistan-based groups exploit regional instability to target India"
- Could mention "India's concerns about **ISIS-K (Islamic State Khorasan Province)** presence in Afghanistan potentially inspiring lone-wolf attacks"
- Can reference "The **Pulwama attack (2019)** showing how regional terror networks coordinate across borders"
What you wrote:
Impact on India's strategic interests:
1) Challenges to connectivity projects:
India's efforts like the Chabahar Port (Iran) and International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC) face uncertainty due to regional instability.
2) Reduced influence in Afghanistan:
Political influence in Afghanistan reduces India's strategic footprint despite past investments in infrastructure and development.
3) Geopolitical competition:
Pakistan seeks strategic depth in Afghanistan, while China's growing role through the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) and potential extension to Afghanistan limits India's regional influence.
4) Energy and trade disruptions:
Instability hampers India's access to Central Asian energy resources and trade routes.
Impact on India's strategic interests:
1) Challenges to connectivity projects:
India's efforts like the Chabahar Port (Iran) and International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC) face uncertainty due to regional instability.
2) Reduced influence in Afghanistan:
Political influence in Afghanistan reduces India's strategic footprint despite past investments in infrastructure and development.
3) Geopolitical competition:
Pakistan seeks strategic depth in Afghanistan, while China's growing role through the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) and potential extension to Afghanistan limits India's regional influence.
4) Energy and trade disruptions:
Instability hampers India's access to Central Asian energy resources and trade routes.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can elaborate on "India's **$3 billion development assistance** to Afghanistan now at risk due to Taliban rule"
- Could mention "Loss of access to **Salma Dam** and other infrastructure projects that provided India strategic leverage"
- Can include "Concerns about **China's lithium mining interests** in Afghanistan potentially shifting regional resource dynamics"
What you wrote:
Way forward:
1) Strengthening diplomatic engagement with Afghanistan and regional stakeholders.
2) Expanding connectivity through Iran and Central India.
3) Enhancing intelligence cooperation to counter terrorism.
4) Supporting humanitarian and development assistance in Afghanistan to maintain goodwill.
Way forward:
1) Strengthening diplomatic engagement with Afghanistan and regional stakeholders.
2) Expanding connectivity through Iran and Central India.
3) Enhancing intelligence cooperation to counter terrorism.
4) Supporting humanitarian and development assistance in Afghanistan to maintain goodwill.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can specify "Engaging with **Taliban through humanitarian channels** while maintaining principled stance on terrorism"
- Could mention "Strengthening **Quad cooperation** to address regional security challenges"
- Can include "Leveraging **Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO)** platform for regional dialogue"
What you wrote:
The Afghanistan-Pakistan crisis is not a bilateral issue alone but a key driver of regional instability. For India, it poses a serious security threats while constraining strategic and economic ambitions in Eurasia, making proactive diplomacy and regional cooperation essential.
The Afghanistan-Pakistan crisis is not a bilateral issue alone but a key driver of regional instability. For India, it poses a serious security threats while constraining strategic and economic ambitions in Eurasia, making proactive diplomacy and regional cooperation essential.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can end with India's broader vision like "India's approach must balance immediate security concerns with long-term goal of regional connectivity under initiatives like **Gati Shakti**"
- Could reference India's civilizational ties: "Drawing on historical cultural connections, India can play a constructive role in regional stability"
The answer demonstrates good conceptual understanding and covers both security and strategic dimensions comprehensively. However, it needs more specific examples and concrete policy references to strengthen the analysis and show deeper engagement with the topic.
Demand of the Question
- Examine impact on India's security interests
- Examine impact on India's strategic interests
- Show how Afghanistan-Pakistan crisis extends beyond bilateral scope
- Connect regional instability to India's broader concerns
What you wrote:
The Afghanistan - Pakistan relationship has remained volatile due to issues like border disputes (DURAND), cross-border terrorism, and the role of militant groups. This instability has consequences that extend beyond the two countries and significantly affect India's security and strategic environment.
The Afghanistan - Pakistan relationship has remained volatile due to issues like border disputes (DURAND), cross-border terrorism, and the role of militant groups. This instability has consequences that extend beyond the two countries and significantly affect India's security and strategic environment.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can begin with recent context like "The Taliban's return to power in 2021 has intensified the Afghanistan-Pakistan crisis, creating new security challenges for regional stability"
- Could briefly mention India's strategic stakes in the region to set up the analysis
More Challenges
View All- View Challenge
GS2
International Relations
3 Jul, 2026
"Birthright citizenship reflects the balance between constitutional guarantees and sovereign control over immigration." Examine this statement with reference to the recent U.S. Supreme Court judgment upholding birthright citizenship and discuss its relevance in the Indian constitutional framework.
- View Challenge
GS3
Disaster Management
Yesterday
“Earthquakes become disasters not merely due to tectonic shocks, but due to weak preparedness.” Examine this with reference to the Venezuelan earthquake and discuss how India should strengthen post-disaster risk mitigation and adaptation.
- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
30 Jun, 2026
"The constitutional guarantee of religious freedom does not confer absolute immunity from State regulation." Examine this statement with reference to Article 25(2) and Article 26(b) in the context of State control over temple administration.
SuperKalam is your personal mentor for UPSC preparation, guiding you at every step of the exam journey.
Download the App
STUDY RESOURCES
CONTACT US
ⓒ Snapstack Technologies Private Limited