Score:
6.5/10
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
Topper’s Copy
GS1
Art & Culture
10 marks
“INSV Kaundinya represents the revival of India’s ancient maritime traditions and highlights the continuity of indigenous shipbuilding knowledge.”
Examine the statement with reference to the technological features, cultural symbolism, and historical maritime linkages of India.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Demand of the Question
- Examine technological features of INSV Kaundinya and their connection to ancient practices
- Analyze cultural symbolism embedded in the vessel
- Explore historical maritime linkages and India's ancient naval traditions
- Assess how the vessel represents revival and continuity of indigenous knowledge
What you wrote:
INSV Kaundinya symbolizes the continuity of India's ancient maritime and shipbuilding traditions, demonstrating that indigenous nautical knowledge has endured from antiquity to the present.
INSV Kaundinya symbolizes the continuity of India's ancient maritime and shipbuilding traditions, demonstrating that indigenous nautical knowledge has endured from antiquity to the present.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could enhance with a specific historical context (like mentioning India's 2,000-year-old maritime history from Harappan ports to Chola naval expeditions) to set a stronger foundation for examining continuity.
What you wrote:
Technological Continuity
The vessel is constructed using the stitched-ship technique, where wooden planks are sewn together with coir ropes without nails, reflecting ancient Indian practices described in texts like the Yuktikalpataru. The Tankai method of hull construction enhances flexibility and seaworthiness, suited for long ocean voyages across the Indian Ocean, as undertaken by early Indian traders.
Technological Continuity
The vessel is constructed using the stitched-ship technique, where wooden planks are sewn together with coir ropes without nails, reflecting ancient Indian practices described in texts like the Yuktikalpataru. The Tankai method of hull construction enhances flexibility and seaworthiness, suited for long ocean voyages across the Indian Ocean, as undertaken by early Indian traders.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could elaborate on additional ancient techniques (like the mortise and tenon joints used in Lothal shipyard dating to 2400 BCE, or the compass and navigation methods described in ancient texts like Brihat Samhita)
- Can mention how these techniques compare with modern shipbuilding (demonstrating both continuity and adaptation to contemporary needs)
What you wrote:
Cultural Symbolism
INSV Kaundinya incorporates motifs such as the Gandabherunda, symbolising strength and protection, and the Simla Yali, associated with auspiciousness and guardianship. These symbols reflect India's civilisational ethos, where ships were not merely transport vehicles but cultural and sacred entities.
Cultural Symbolism
INSV Kaundinya incorporates motifs such as the Gandabherunda, symbolising strength and protection, and the Simla Yali, associated with auspiciousness and guardianship. These symbols reflect India's civilisational ethos, where ships were not merely transport vehicles but cultural and sacred entities.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could expand on additional symbolic elements (like Makara motifs representing sea creatures, or Swastika symbols for auspiciousness commonly found on ancient Indian vessels)
- Can discuss how these symbols reflect India's maritime cosmology where ocean voyages were considered sacred journeys requiring divine protection
What you wrote:
Historical Maritime Linkages
Named after Kaundinya, the legendary Indian mariner who established ties with Funan (Southeast Asia), the ship evokes India's ancient role in Indian Ocean trade networks, facilitating cultural exchange, commerce and the spread of Indic ideas.
Historical Maritime Linkages
Named after Kaundinya, the legendary Indian mariner who established ties with Funan (Southeast Asia), the ship evokes India's ancient role in Indian Ocean trade networks, facilitating cultural exchange, commerce and the spread of Indic ideas.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could elaborate on India's extensive maritime networks (like the Chola naval expeditions to Southeast Asia in 11th century, trade with Roman Empire through Red Sea ports, and the monsoon-based trading system that connected India to Arabia and Africa)
- Can mention specific historical evidence (like Periplus of the Erythraean Sea documenting Indian maritime trade, or archaeological findings at Arikamedu and Muziris ports)
What you wrote:
Present-day relevance
INSV Kaundinya reinforces indigenous knowledge systems, strengthens cultural diplomacy, and reasserts India's maritime identity as a soft power in the Indo-Pacific era.
Present-day relevance
INSV Kaundinya reinforces indigenous knowledge systems, strengthens cultural diplomacy, and reasserts India's maritime identity as a soft power in the Indo-Pacific era.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could strengthen by mentioning specific government initiatives (like the Sagarmala Project for port modernization or Maritime India Vision 2030) that demonstrate how ancient maritime wisdom informs modern policy, creating a stronger link between past and present.
Your answer demonstrates good understanding of the topic with specific examples and clear thematic organization. However, it could benefit from deeper historical context and broader exploration of India's maritime achievements to fully address the examination demand of historical linkages.
Demand of the Question
- Examine technological features of INSV Kaundinya and their connection to ancient practices
- Analyze cultural symbolism embedded in the vessel
- Explore historical maritime linkages and India's ancient naval traditions
- Assess how the vessel represents revival and continuity of indigenous knowledge
What you wrote:
INSV Kaundinya symbolizes the continuity of India's ancient maritime and shipbuilding traditions, demonstrating that indigenous nautical knowledge has endured from antiquity to the present.
INSV Kaundinya symbolizes the continuity of India's ancient maritime and shipbuilding traditions, demonstrating that indigenous nautical knowledge has endured from antiquity to the present.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could enhance with a specific historical context (like mentioning India's 2,000-year-old maritime history from Harappan ports to Chola naval expeditions) to set a stronger foundation for examining continuity.
More Challenges
View All- View Challenge
GS3
Science & Technology
11 Jan, 2026
“Despite the availability of cost-effective preventive interventions, India continues to report a high burden of neural tube defects such as Spina Bifida.”
In this context, examine the role of pre-conceptional folic acid supplementation and food fortification in preventing Spina Bifida in India. Discuss the challenges in implementation and suggest policy measures to address them. - View Challenge
GS3
Environment & Ecology
Yesterday
“The debate over conservation of the Western Ghats reflects the tension between ecological sustainability and developmental priorities.”
In this context, critically examine the recommendations of the Western Ghats Expert Ecology Panel (WGEEP) and the Kasturirangan Committee, highlighting their implications for environmental governance in India. - View Challenge
GS3
Economy
9 Jan, 2026
“The introduction of Public–Private Partnership (PPP) model medical colleges in tribal districts marks a shift in India’s approach to healthcare capacity building.”
In this context, examine the rationale behind adopting the PPP model for medical education in tribal regions. Discuss its potential benefits and challenges in ensuring equity, quality of healthcare delivery, and public accountability.
