Q3. How difficult would have been the achievement of Indian independence without Mahatma Gandhi? Discuss.

Model Answer:

Introduction

The Indian independence movement spanned over a century, with various leaders, ideologies, and movements contributing to the cause. Mahatma Gandhi emerged as the central figure in the 20th century, shaping the movement with his philosophy of non-violence and mass mobilisation. His contribution is seen as pivotal, but it is worth considering how the struggle might have evolved without him.

Body

Absence of Non-Violent Philosophy:

• Gandhi's emphasis on ahimsa (non-violence) and Satyagraha (truth force) gave the movement a moral high ground, preventing large-scale violence.
• Without Gandhi, the movement might have veered more towards violent uprisings, like those led by revolutionaries such as Bhagat Singh and Subhas Chandra Bose, risking greater repression by the British.

Lack of Mass Mobilization:

• Gandhi’s leadership turned the independence struggle into a mass movement, involving peasants, women, and people from various castes and communities.
• Without him, the movement may have remained confined to the educated elite or militant groups, limiting its impact on a national scale.

Absence of Unified Leadership:

• Gandhi acted as a unifying force, managing internal differences within the Congress Party and bridging gaps between moderates and extremists.
• In his absence, deep ideological rifts could have fractured the movement, weakening its overall momentum.

Global Influence:

• Gandhi’s non-violent philosophy attracted international attention and sympathy for the Indian cause.
• Without him, global support and pressure on the British government may have been less effective, slowing the process of independence.

Conclusion:

While Indian independence might have been achieved without Mahatma Gandhi, it likely would have been a longer, more violent, and fractured process. Gandhi’s strategies not only mobilised the masses but also brought a moral dimension to the movement, accelerating the British exit and setting the tone for India’s post-independence democratic values. His absence would have altered the nature and timing of freedom.

‍

Instant Mains Evaluation with SuperKalam