Score:
6.5/10
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
Topper’s Copy
GS2
Internal Security
10 marks
Discuss the role of ship-based air defence systems like Shtil in strengthening India’s maritime security. Highlight their key features and strategic significance.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Demand of the Question
- Role of ship-based air defence systems (specifically Shtil) in maritime security
- Key features of these systems
- Strategic significance for India's maritime security
What you wrote:
with increasing threats from drones, anti-ship missiles, and carrier based aircraft (2024-25 indo-Pacific tensions), systems like the Shtil-1 air defence missile deployed on Indian Navy frigates (Talwar/Grigorovich Class) enhance fleet survivability.
with increasing threats from drones, anti-ship missiles, and carrier based aircraft (2024-25 indo-Pacific tensions), systems like the Shtil-1 air defence missile deployed on Indian Navy frigates (Talwar/Grigorovich Class) enhance fleet survivability.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can begin with a recent maritime security incident (e.g., Houthis' drone attacks on commercial shipping in Red Sea 2024 demonstrated vulnerability of naval assets to aerial threats)
What you wrote:
Key features of Shtil-1
1) Vertical launch system (VLS) for 360° engagement.
2) Capable of intercepting aircraft, UVVs, and sea-skimming missiles.
3) Medium range surface-to-Air Missile (SAM). (~50-70Km).
4) High reaction speed and multi-target engagement capability.
Key features of Shtil-1
1) Vertical launch system (VLS) for 360° engagement.
2) Capable of intercepting aircraft, UVVs, and sea-skimming missiles.
3) Medium range surface-to-Air Missile (SAM). (~50-70Km).
4) High reaction speed and multi-target engagement capability.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can add radar integration details (e.g., MR-760 Fregat radar system provides target acquisition and tracking for Shtil missiles)
- Could mention engagement altitude capabilities (can intercept targets from sea level to 25km altitude)
What you wrote:
Role in Maritime Security
1) Protects ships from missile and aerial threats in contested waters.
2) Enhances operational capability in carrier battle groups.
3) Protects ships from missile and aerial threats in Contested waters.
4) Supports layered defence architecture with Barak-8 and CIWS.
Role in Maritime Security
1) Protects ships from missile and aerial threats in contested waters.
2) Enhances operational capability in carrier battle groups.
3) Protects ships from missile and aerial threats in Contested waters.
4) Supports layered defence architecture with Barak-8 and CIWS.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can elaborate on chokepoint security (e.g., Strait of Hormuz, Malacca Strait where 25% of global trade passes)
- Could discuss convoy protection role during wartime scenarios
- Can mention anti-submarine warfare support by engaging maritime patrol aircraft
What you wrote:
Strategic Significance
1) Counters emerging threats from China's naval expansion.
2) Contributes to Atmanirbhar Bharat through integration with indigenous systems.
3) Strengthens India's role as a net security provider in IOR.
4) Improves survivability in high-intensity maritime conflicts.
Strategic Significance
1) Counters emerging threats from China's naval expansion.
2) Contributes to Atmanirbhar Bharat through integration with indigenous systems.
3) Strengthens India's role as a net security provider in IOR.
4) Improves survivability in high-intensity maritime conflicts.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can add specific threat scenarios (e.g., PLA Navy's Type 055 destroyers equipped with YJ-18 anti-ship missiles pose direct challenges)
- Could mention interoperability with Quad partners during joint naval exercises like Malabar
What you wrote:
Ship-based air defence systems like Shtil are crucial for ensuring fleet protection and maritime dominance, enabling India to safeguard its interests in the evolving indo-pacific security environment.
Ship-based air defence systems like Shtil are crucial for ensuring fleet protection and maritime dominance, enabling India to safeguard its interests in the evolving indo-pacific security environment.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can conclude with future modernization plans (e.g., integration with Project 17B frigates and upcoming Project 18 destroyers for comprehensive fleet coverage)
- Could reference Make in India initiatives for indigenous air defence systems development
Your answer demonstrates strong technical knowledge and strategic understanding of maritime air defence systems. The structure is well-organized with clear coverage of all demands, though some repetition and missing chokepoint analysis could be addressed.
Demand of the Question
- Role of ship-based air defence systems (specifically Shtil) in maritime security
- Key features of these systems
- Strategic significance for India's maritime security
What you wrote:
with increasing threats from drones, anti-ship missiles, and carrier based aircraft (2024-25 indo-Pacific tensions), systems like the Shtil-1 air defence missile deployed on Indian Navy frigates (Talwar/Grigorovich Class) enhance fleet survivability.
with increasing threats from drones, anti-ship missiles, and carrier based aircraft (2024-25 indo-Pacific tensions), systems like the Shtil-1 air defence missile deployed on Indian Navy frigates (Talwar/Grigorovich Class) enhance fleet survivability.
Suggestions to improve:
- Can begin with a recent maritime security incident (e.g., Houthis' drone attacks on commercial shipping in Red Sea 2024 demonstrated vulnerability of naval assets to aerial threats)
More Challenges
View All- View Challenge
GS2
International Relations
14 Aug, 2026
Power trade is emerging as an important instrument of India’s neighbourhood diplomacy. Examine how electricity cooperation with Bangladesh, Nepal and Bhutan can advance India’s strategic and economic interests while promoting regional integration.
- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
Yesterday
The FCRA Amendment Bill, 2026 seeks to strengthen state oversight over foreign-funded organisations while raising concerns about civil society autonomy. Critically examine.
- View Challenge
GS3
Economy
12 Aug, 2026
The next phase of India's MSME growth lies not merely in creating more enterprises, but in clustering them. Examine how a cluster-based approach can enhance the productivity and global competitiveness of Indian MSMEs.
SuperKalam is your personal mentor for UPSC preparation, guiding you at every step of the exam journey.
Download the App
STUDY RESOURCES
CONTACT US
ⓒ Snapstack Technologies Private Limited