Score:
7/15
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
Topper’s Copy
GS2
International Relations
15 marks
The G7, once the steering committee of the global economy, is today seen as an institution in churn, struggling for relevance amid shifting power equations." Examine the validity of this statement.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Demand of the Question
- Examine the validity of G7's declining relevance claim
- Historical context - G7 as former "steering committee"
- Current challenges - "institution in churn" and struggles
- Shifting power equations - impact on G7's position
- Balanced assessment - both declining and continuing relevance
- Contemporary examples supporting the argument
What you wrote:
The G7, comprising the US, UK, Canada, France, Germany, Italy and Japan has traditionally shaped Global economic governance. However the rise of China and other emerging economies has led to debates regarding the declining relevance of the grouping.
The G7, comprising the US, UK, Canada, France, Germany, Italy and Japan has traditionally shaped Global economic governance. However the rise of China and other emerging economies has led to debates regarding the declining relevance of the grouping.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could begin with G7's historical dominance (e.g., controlling 70% of global GDP in the 1970s vs. current 45%)
- Can reference recent developments like India's G20 presidency in 2023 highlighting emerging economies' growing influence
What you wrote:
Why G17 is losing relevance
[DRAWING: A central box labeled "Why G17 is losing relevance" has two boxes branching out from it: "Shift in Economic Power" and "China's Expanding Influence". "Shift in Economic Power" has an arrow pointing to a box labeled "Rise of Alternative Platforms". "China's Expanding Influence" has an arrow pointing to a box labeled "Internal Divisions within G7".]
1] Shift in Economic Power
- China's share in global GDP has risen sharply. Emerging economies like India and Brazil have become Major growth engines.
2] Rise of Alternative Platforms
- BRICS, SCO and G20 provide more inclusive representation.
- G20 Now accounts for around 85% of global GDP.
3] China's Expanding Influence
- Belt and Road Initiatives (BRI), AIIB and growing trade links have enhanced China's global reach.
4] Internal Divisions within G7
- Differences over trade, Climate Commitments and security issues reduce cohesion.
Why G17 is losing relevance
[DRAWING: A central box labeled "Why G17 is losing relevance" has two boxes branching out from it: "Shift in Economic Power" and "China's Expanding Influence". "Shift in Economic Power" has an arrow pointing to a box labeled "Rise of Alternative Platforms". "China's Expanding Influence" has an arrow pointing to a box labeled "Internal Divisions within G7".]
1] Shift in Economic Power
- China's share in global GDP has risen sharply. Emerging economies like India and Brazil have become Major growth engines.
2] Rise of Alternative Platforms
- BRICS, SCO and G20 provide more inclusive representation.
- G20 Now accounts for around 85% of global GDP.
3] China's Expanding Influence
- Belt and Road Initiatives (BRI), AIIB and growing trade links have enhanced China's global reach.
4] Internal Divisions within G7
- Differences over trade, Climate Commitments and security issues reduce cohesion.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could quantify economic shifts (e.g., China's GDP grew from 4% to 17% of global total since 2000)
- Can cite specific G7 divisions like disagreements over Russia sanctions implementation or climate finance commitments
- Could highlight BRICS expansion in 2023 (adding Saudi Arabia, UAE, Egypt) as direct challenge to G7 exclusivity
- Can mention AIIB's 100+ member countries vs. G7-dominated World Bank
What you wrote:
G7 is Still Important
[DRAWING: A central box labeled "G7 is Still Important" has arrows pointing to four different boxes: "Strong Economies", "Technological leadership", "Ability to influence global issues", and "Major role in global institutions".]
1] Strong Economies
- G7 countries are still among the richest and most advanced Economies.
2] Technological leadership
- They lead in areas such as Artificial Intelligence, Innovation and finance.
3] Ability to Influence global issues
- They work together on Climate Change, Energy security and International conflicts.
4] Major role in global Institutions
- They continue to have significant influence in Institutions like the IMF and World Bank.
G7 is Still Important
[DRAWING: A central box labeled "G7 is Still Important" has arrows pointing to four different boxes: "Strong Economies", "Technological leadership", "Ability to influence global issues", and "Major role in global institutions".]
1] Strong Economies
- G7 countries are still among the richest and most advanced Economies.
2] Technological leadership
- They lead in areas such as Artificial Intelligence, Innovation and finance.
3] Ability to Influence global issues
- They work together on Climate Change, Energy security and International conflicts.
4] Major role in global Institutions
- They continue to have significant influence in Institutions like the IMF and World Bank.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could cite specific achievements like G7's $600 billion Partnership for Global Infrastructure as counter to BRI
- Can highlight G7's coordinated response to COVID-19 with vaccine donations and economic support
- Could mention G7's leadership in AI governance frameworks and semiconductor supply chain security
- Can reference G7's role in coordinating Ukraine support demonstrating continued crisis management capability
What you wrote:
As the World Moves towards Multipolarity, the G17 remains important, but no longer acts as a sole steering committee of the global Economy.
As the World Moves towards Multipolarity, the G17 remains important, but no longer acts as a sole steering committee of the global Economy.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could emphasize adaptive strategies G7 is adopting (e.g., outreach to Global South, partnership with emerging economies)
- Can conclude with future trajectory - whether G7 can reinvent itself as a "values-based coalition" rather than just economic club
Strong structural organization with effective use of visual mapping and balanced argumentation. However, the answer lacks specific data, recent examples, and deeper analysis of the mechanisms behind G7's transformation in global governance.
Demand of the Question
- Examine the validity of G7's declining relevance claim
- Historical context - G7 as former "steering committee"
- Current challenges - "institution in churn" and struggles
- Shifting power equations - impact on G7's position
- Balanced assessment - both declining and continuing relevance
- Contemporary examples supporting the argument
What you wrote:
The G7, comprising the US, UK, Canada, France, Germany, Italy and Japan has traditionally shaped Global economic governance. However the rise of China and other emerging economies has led to debates regarding the declining relevance of the grouping.
The G7, comprising the US, UK, Canada, France, Germany, Italy and Japan has traditionally shaped Global economic governance. However the rise of China and other emerging economies has led to debates regarding the declining relevance of the grouping.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could begin with G7's historical dominance (e.g., controlling 70% of global GDP in the 1970s vs. current 45%)
- Can reference recent developments like India's G20 presidency in 2023 highlighting emerging economies' growing influence
More Challenges
View All- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
11 Jul, 2026
“Judicial independence cannot become a shield against judicial accountability.” Examine this statement in light of the constitutional process for removing judges and the accountability concerns raised by a judge resigning during pending removal proceedings.
- View Challenge
GS2
International Relations
Yesterday
"Critical minerals have emerged as the new strategic resources of the 21st century." Discuss their significance for India's economic and strategic security. Examine how international partnerships can strengthen India's critical mineral ecosystem.
- View Challenge
GS3
Economy
9 Jul, 2026
"The success of ethanol blending depends as much on fuel quality and vehicle compatibility as on blending targets." Examine this statement in the context of India's transition towards E20 fuel.
SuperKalam is your personal mentor for UPSC preparation, guiding you at every step of the exam journey.
Download the App
STUDY RESOURCES
CONTACT US
ⓒ Snapstack Technologies Private Limited