Topper’s Copy

GS2

Indian Polity

10 marks

Discuss the constitutional position, powers, and functions of the Lieutenant Governor in Union Territories with special reference to Delhi.

Student’s Answer

Evaluation by SuperKalam

icon

Score:

4.5/10

0
3
6
10

Demand of the Question

  • Constitutional position of LG in UTs
  • Powers and functions of LG
  • Special reference to Delhi's unique status
  • Constitutional provisions and legal framework

What you wrote:

The Lieutenant Governor (LG) functions as administrator of Union Territories under Article 239, but Article 239AA grants Delhi a unique status.

The Lieutenant Governor (LG) functions as administrator of Union Territories under Article 239, but Article 239AA grants Delhi a unique status.

Suggestions to improve:

  • Could elaborate on Delhi's quasi-state status (e.g., Delhi being the only UT with a Legislative Assembly and Council of Ministers under Article 239AA)
  • Can contextualize LG's dual role as both UT administrator and representative of President in national capital

What you wrote:

[DRAWING: A central oval is labelled "Powers & Functions". It has three lines branching out to three other ovals.
The oval on the left is labelled "Executive". Text below it reads: "LG is bound by 'aid & advice' of Council of Ministers except on 'reserved' subjects such Public Order, Police & Land where he exercises absolute authority."
The oval on the right is labelled "Legislative". Text below it reads: "Includes summoning the Assembly & reserving Bills for President's consideration."
The oval at the bottom is labelled "Discretionary."]

[DRAWING: A central oval is labelled "Powers & Functions". It has three lines branching out to three other ovals.
The oval on the left is labelled "Executive". Text below it reads: "LG is bound by 'aid & advice' of Council of Ministers except on 'reserved' subjects such Public Order, Police & Land where he exercises absolute authority."
The oval on the right is labelled "Legislative". Text below it reads: "Includes summoning the Assembly & reserving Bills for President's consideration."
The oval at the bottom is labelled "Discretionary."]

Suggestions to improve:

  • Could detail Article 239A provisions (e.g., LG acts on aid and advice except in matters where President/LG has discretionary powers)
  • Can include comparison with Puducherry's LG powers under Article 239A to highlight Delhi's unique position
  • Could mention Article 239AB regarding disqualification of MLAs in Delhi

What you wrote:

Under GNCTD (Amendment) Act, 2021, "Government" in Delhi means LG, expanding his oversight or executive decisions.

Critical Dimension:
1) Frequent friction exists over administrative control.
2) In GNCTD v Union of India (2018), Supreme Court ruled the LG is not an "independent decision maker" & must respect the representative democracy, though 2023 ruling & subsequent Ordinance reaffirmed Central control over "Services."

Under GNCTD (Amendment) Act, 2021, "Government" in Delhi means LG, expanding his oversight or executive decisions.

Critical Dimension:
1) Frequent friction exists over administrative control.
2) In GNCTD v Union of India (2018), Supreme Court ruled the LG is not an "independent decision maker" & must respect the representative democracy, though 2023 ruling & subsequent Ordinance reaffirmed Central control over "Services."

Suggestions to improve:

  • Could clarify the Supreme Court's five-judge bench ruling in GNCTD v. Union of India (2018) that LG must act on aid and advice of elected government except on reserved subjects
  • Can mention Article 239B regarding creation of High Courts for UTs and LG's role in judicial administration
  • Could include recent developments like the Services matter dispute and its resolution through ordinances

What you wrote:

LG's role necessitates a fine balance between federal supremacy & the democratic aspirations of Delhi's electorate.

LG's role necessitates a fine balance between federal supremacy & the democratic aspirations of Delhi's electorate.

Suggestions to improve:

  • Can conclude with Punchhi Commission recommendations on UT governance reforms (e.g., clearer demarcation of powers between LG and elected government)
  • Could reference the need for constitutional clarity through potential amendments to Article 239AA for better governance

Strong constitutional foundation with good visual presentation and relevant case law references. However, the comparative aspect with other UTs and detailed constitutional provisions need strengthening for comprehensive coverage.

Demand of the Question

  • Constitutional position of LG in UTs
  • Powers and functions of LG
  • Special reference to Delhi's unique status
  • Constitutional provisions and legal framework

What you wrote:

The Lieutenant Governor (LG) functions as administrator of Union Territories under Article 239, but Article 239AA grants Delhi a unique status.

The Lieutenant Governor (LG) functions as administrator of Union Territories under Article 239, but Article 239AA grants Delhi a unique status.

Suggestions to improve:

  • Could elaborate on Delhi's quasi-state status (e.g., Delhi being the only UT with a Legislative Assembly and Council of Ministers under Article 239AA)
  • Can contextualize LG's dual role as both UT administrator and representative of President in national capital

More Challenges

View All
  • GS3

    Disaster Management

    22 Nov, 2026

    What are the causes of landslides in the Western Ghats? Discuss the role of early warning systems in landslide risk reduction.

    View Challenge
  • GS2

    Governance

    Yesterday

    What are the major risks associated with using Generative AI in governance? Suggest measures to ensure accuracy, transparency and accountability in its use.

    View Challenge
  • GS3

    Economy

    20 Nov, 2026

    What are the major challenges facing India's power sector? Suggest measures to ensure reliable and affordable electricity supply.

    View Challenge
SuperKalam
SuperKalam is your personal mentor for UPSC preparation, guiding you at every step of the exam journey.

Download the App

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Follow us

ⓒ Snapstack Technologies Private Limited