Score:
5.5/10
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
Topper’s Copy
GS2
International Relations
10 marks
The United Nations is undergoing institutional reform through initiatives such as the UN80 Initiative. Examine the need for reforms in the United Nations system in the context of contemporary global challenges.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Demand of the Question
- Need for UN reforms in current global context
- Contemporary global challenges requiring UN adaptation
- Analysis of UN80 Initiative as reform mechanism
- Structural/functional limitations of current UN system
What you wrote:
United Nations was established in 1945 after the devastation in WWII to maintain international peace, promote cooperation and uphold human rights. However, the rapidly evolving global order has exposed structural and functional limitations in the UN System. Initiatives such as the UN80 Initiative launched on the 80th Anniversary of the organization is an effort at tackling contemporary challenges.
United Nations was established in 1945 after the devastation in WWII to maintain international peace, promote cooperation and uphold human rights. However, the rapidly evolving global order has exposed structural and functional limitations in the UN System. Initiatives such as the UN80 Initiative launched on the 80th Anniversary of the organization is an effort at tackling contemporary challenges.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could strengthen by briefly mentioning specific contemporary challenges (e.g., "challenges ranging from climate emergencies to cyber warfare that were unimaginable in 1945")
What you wrote:
[DRAWING: A central oval labelled "UN80 Initiative" has three arrows pointing outwards to three rectangular boxes. The first arrow points to a box with the text "1. Efficiency & Footprint - Streamlining UN's Global Presence by relocating functions to lower-cost duty stations". The second arrow points to a box with the text "2. Mandate Review - Evaluating over 3600 mandates to determine which programs are still relevant & which can be consolidated." The third arrow points to a box with the text "Structural Realignment - Proposing mergers of overlapping agencies to create a more integrated 'One UN' Approach."]
[DRAWING: A central oval labelled "UN80 Initiative" has three arrows pointing outwards to three rectangular boxes. The first arrow points to a box with the text "1. Efficiency & Footprint - Streamlining UN's Global Presence by relocating functions to lower-cost duty stations". The second arrow points to a box with the text "2. Mandate Review - Evaluating over 3600 mandates to determine which programs are still relevant & which can be consolidated." The third arrow points to a box with the text "Structural Realignment - Proposing mergers of overlapping agencies to create a more integrated 'One UN' Approach."]
Suggestions to improve:
- Could integrate diagram analysis within the text by explaining how these three pillars address specific UN limitations
- Can elaborate on mandate review covering over 3,600 programs to show scale of bureaucratic complexity
- Could connect "One UN" approach to examples like UN Country Teams coordination in humanitarian crises
What you wrote:
Need for Reforms
1. Changing Global Power Dynamics – Global balance has shifted significantly but institutions such as the UNSC still reflect post-WWII order. This mismatch undermines the legitimacy and representativeness of UN system.
2. Inefficiencies in Institutional Functioning: Multiple agencies & of overlapping mandates often lead to bureaucratic delays and duplication of efforts.
3. Emerging Global Challenges: Modern threats such as climate change, cyber security risks, terrorism and pandemics require coordinated global responses.
4. Declining Trust in Multilateralism: Increasing geopolitical rivalries & unilateral actions by major powers have weakened confidence in multilateral institutions.
5. Demand for Greater Inclusivity & Representation by developing countries & regions in global decision-making.
Need for Reforms
1. Changing Global Power Dynamics – Global balance has shifted significantly but institutions such as the UNSC still reflect post-WWII order. This mismatch undermines the legitimacy and representativeness of UN system.
2. Inefficiencies in Institutional Functioning: Multiple agencies & of overlapping mandates often lead to bureaucratic delays and duplication of efforts.
3. Emerging Global Challenges: Modern threats such as climate change, cyber security risks, terrorism and pandemics require coordinated global responses.
4. Declining Trust in Multilateralism: Increasing geopolitical rivalries & unilateral actions by major powers have weakened confidence in multilateral institutions.
5. Demand for Greater Inclusivity & Representation by developing countries & regions in global decision-making.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could provide concrete examples like India's long-standing bid for permanent UNSC membership representing 1.4 billion people
- Can illustrate bureaucratic inefficiency with cases like overlapping humanitarian responses during COVID-19 pandemic
- Could link emerging challenges to specific UN failures, such as delayed response to cyber attacks on critical infrastructure
- Can mention Africa's underrepresentation with only 3 of 15 UNSC seats despite 54 member countries
What you wrote:
In an era marked by interconnected global challenges, the effectiveness of international governance depends on a responsive and credible multilateral system. As Antonio Guterres stated in his speech - "1945 problem solving will not solve 2026 problems."
In an era marked by interconnected global challenges, the effectiveness of international governance depends on a responsive and credible multilateral system. As Antonio Guterres stated in his speech - "1945 problem solving will not solve 2026 problems."
Suggestions to improve:
- Could strengthen by connecting reform initiatives to India's vision, such as India's advocacy for "reformed multilateralism" during G20 presidency
- Can conclude with specific reform outcomes needed, like expansion of UNSC permanent membership to include major developing economies
Strong foundational understanding with good use of visual elements and comprehensive coverage of reform needs. However, lacks specific examples and concrete connections between identified problems and proposed solutions through UN80 Initiative.
Demand of the Question
- Need for UN reforms in current global context
- Contemporary global challenges requiring UN adaptation
- Analysis of UN80 Initiative as reform mechanism
- Structural/functional limitations of current UN system
What you wrote:
United Nations was established in 1945 after the devastation in WWII to maintain international peace, promote cooperation and uphold human rights. However, the rapidly evolving global order has exposed structural and functional limitations in the UN System. Initiatives such as the UN80 Initiative launched on the 80th Anniversary of the organization is an effort at tackling contemporary challenges.
United Nations was established in 1945 after the devastation in WWII to maintain international peace, promote cooperation and uphold human rights. However, the rapidly evolving global order has exposed structural and functional limitations in the UN System. Initiatives such as the UN80 Initiative launched on the 80th Anniversary of the organization is an effort at tackling contemporary challenges.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could strengthen by briefly mentioning specific contemporary challenges (e.g., "challenges ranging from climate emergencies to cyber warfare that were unimaginable in 1945")
More Challenges
View All- View Challenge
GS2
Governance
27 Jul, 2026
India's examination system is due for structural reforms to meet the demands of a knowledge-driven economy. Examine the key challenges in the existing examination system and discuss how technology-driven reforms can improve its credibility, inclusiveness and effectiveness.
- View Challenge
GS3
Economy
Yesterday
The global race for Artificial Intelligence is reshaping the semiconductor industry and increasing the cost of electronics worldwide. Examine the economic implications of rising chip prices for India. Suggest measures to strengthen India's semiconductor ecosystem.
- View Challenge
GS3
Disaster Management
25 Jul, 2026
Recurring floods in India are increasingly becoming a consequence of developmental and governance failures rather than natural phenomena alone. Examine this statement in the light of the recent Assam floods. Suggest measures for building long-term flood resilience.
SuperKalam is your personal mentor for UPSC preparation, guiding you at every step of the exam journey.
Download the App
STUDY RESOURCES
CONTACT US
ⓒ Snapstack Technologies Private Limited