In the Indian governance system, the
role of non-state actors has been only
marginal.” Critically examine this
statement.
In the Indian governance system, the
role of non-state actors has been only
marginal.” Critically examine this
statement.
Subject: Governance
The emergence of non-state actors as vital partners in governance is evident from India having 187,395 registered NGOs as of October 2023, demonstrating their significant rather than marginal role in complementing government efforts across various sectors.
Role and Contributions of Non-State Actors
-
Policy Advocacy and Implementation:
- NGOs actively participate in policy formulation through research, advocacy, and grassroots feedback (e.g., Vanashakti's petition leading to Supreme Court review of pesticide ban in 2023).
- They serve as implementation partners for government schemes like MGNREGA and National Health Mission.
-
Service Delivery and Last Mile Connectivity:
- Non-state actors bridge crucial gaps in public service delivery, especially in remote areas.
- Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) initiatives by private sector complement government efforts in education, healthcare, and skill development.
-
Resource Mobilization:
- Multiple funding sources including government grants, CSR contributions, and foreign donations enable sustainable operations.
- Crowdfunding and individual philanthropy demonstrate public trust in these organizations.
Challenges and Limitations
-
Regulatory Framework:
- The FCRA Amendment Act 2020 restrictions on foreign funding affect operational capacity.
- Supreme Court's upholding of FCRA provisions in 2022 impacts resource mobilization.
-
Coordination Issues:
- Lack of synchronized efforts between government and non-state actors.
- Limited institutional mechanisms for partnership and collaboration.
Way Forward
-
Strengthening Partnerships:
- Development of formal frameworks for government-NGO collaboration.
- Enhanced role in policy implementation and monitoring.
-
Capacity Building:
- Investment in organizational development and professional management.
- Focus on transparency and accountability mechanisms.
The statement that non-state actors play only a marginal role appears incorrect given their substantial contributions to Indian governance. Their role is exemplified by successful initiatives like the Violence Prevention Forum and various social programs, making them indispensable partners in India's development journey alongside the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) framework.
Answer Length
Model answers may exceed the word limit for better clarity and depth. Use them as a guide, but always frame your final answer within the exam’s prescribed limit.
In just 60 sec
Evaluate your handwritten answer
- Get detailed feedback
- Model Answer after evaluation
Crack UPSC with your
Personal AI Mentor
An AI-powered ecosystem to learn, practice, and evaluate with discipline
Start Now