Score:
6/10
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
Topper’s Copy
GS3
Environment & Ecology
10 marks
“The conservation of species in India has increasingly shifted from a species-centric approach to a landscape and community-based model.”
Examine this statement in the context of conservation initiatives for species such as the Snow Leopard, Asiatic Cheetah and Gangetic River Dolphin.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Demand of the Question
- Examine the shift from species-centric to landscape and community-based conservation models
- Analyze this transition specifically through Snow Leopard, Asiatic Cheetah, and Gangetic River Dolphin conservation initiatives
What you wrote:
Historically, India followed the fortress conservation model focusing on protecting specific flagship species (Tiger) within strictly demarcated, people-free protected areas. Modern conservation acknowledges the ecosystems are interconnected. It focuses on large biological landscapes (habitats + corridors) and recognizes local communities as the primary stakeholders rather than "encroachers". The case studies.
Historically, India followed the fortress conservation model focusing on protecting specific flagship species (Tiger) within strictly demarcated, people-free protected areas. Modern conservation acknowledges the ecosystems are interconnected. It focuses on large biological landscapes (habitats + corridors) and recognizes local communities as the primary stakeholders rather than "encroachers". The case studies.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could briefly mention a specific data point (e.g., India's 5% of global biodiversity across 2.4% land area necessitating landscape approaches) to strengthen the opening.
What you wrote:
(a) Snow Leopard
- Landscape Based Approach: Project Snow Leopard operates on the entire Himalayan ecosystem, thereby bridging the gap between protected areas and human-use landscapes.
- Community Integration: Programs like "Himal Sanrakshak" makes local herders as stewards. Livestock insurance and predator-proof corrals reduce retaliatory killings.
(b) Asiatic Cheetah
- Landscape Based Approach: The cheetah is an "Umbrella Species". Reintroduction in Kuno NP focuses on restoring the Grassland-Scrub ecosystem, benefitting the entire food chain.
- Community Integration: Cheetah Mitras (villagers) are trained as protectors and guides, linking conservation to the local economy and social pride.
(c) Gangetic Dolphin
- Project Dolphin treats the river as a whole system. Focus is on maintaining "Environmental flows" and reducing basin-wide pollution.
- Ganga Praharis are engaged in monitoring & preventing plastic/chemical runoff.
(a) Snow Leopard
- Landscape Based Approach: Project Snow Leopard operates on the entire Himalayan ecosystem, thereby bridging the gap between protected areas and human-use landscapes.
- Community Integration: Programs like "Himal Sanrakshak" makes local herders as stewards. Livestock insurance and predator-proof corrals reduce retaliatory killings.
(b) Asiatic Cheetah
- Landscape Based Approach: The cheetah is an "Umbrella Species". Reintroduction in Kuno NP focuses on restoring the Grassland-Scrub ecosystem, benefitting the entire food chain.
- Community Integration: Cheetah Mitras (villagers) are trained as protectors and guides, linking conservation to the local economy and social pride.
(c) Gangetic Dolphin
- Project Dolphin treats the river as a whole system. Focus is on maintaining "Environmental flows" and reducing basin-wide pollution.
- Ganga Praharis are engaged in monitoring & preventing plastic/chemical runoff.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could incorporate legal-institutional dimension (e.g., Community Reserve provisions under WPA 2006 amendments enabling co-management models like Snow Leopard Conservancies in Ladakh)
- Can add economic incentives data (e.g., livestock insurance schemes reducing human-wildlife conflict by 60% in Himachal Pradesh under Snow Leopard programs)
- Could mention recent expansions (e.g., Project Dolphin 2020 covering entire aquatic ecosystem beyond just Gangetic Dolphin, linking 8 freshwater species conservation)
What you wrote:
The future of Indian conservation lies in co-existence, not exclusion. By integrating the WPA with community-led grassroot movements, India is transitioning from being a protector of animals, to a 'facilitator' of healthy, shared landscapes.
The future of Indian conservation lies in co-existence, not exclusion. By integrating the WPA with community-led grassroot movements, India is transitioning from being a protector of animals, to a 'facilitator' of healthy, shared landscapes.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could strengthen with forward-looking specifics (e.g., integrating traditional ecological knowledge with modern technology like satellite telemetry used in Snow Leopard tracking, or linking to SDG 15 on Life on Land)
- Can mention challenges requiring attention (e.g., balancing development pressures in fragile Himalayan ecosystems while maintaining connectivity corridors)
Well-structured answer demonstrating good understanding of conservation paradigm shift with relevant examples of community integration. However, correct the Asiatic/African Cheetah error and strengthen with specific policy frameworks and recent data to make the examination more comprehensive and accurate.
Demand of the Question
- Examine the shift from species-centric to landscape and community-based conservation models
- Analyze this transition specifically through Snow Leopard, Asiatic Cheetah, and Gangetic River Dolphin conservation initiatives
What you wrote:
Historically, India followed the fortress conservation model focusing on protecting specific flagship species (Tiger) within strictly demarcated, people-free protected areas. Modern conservation acknowledges the ecosystems are interconnected. It focuses on large biological landscapes (habitats + corridors) and recognizes local communities as the primary stakeholders rather than "encroachers". The case studies.
Historically, India followed the fortress conservation model focusing on protecting specific flagship species (Tiger) within strictly demarcated, people-free protected areas. Modern conservation acknowledges the ecosystems are interconnected. It focuses on large biological landscapes (habitats + corridors) and recognizes local communities as the primary stakeholders rather than "encroachers". The case studies.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could briefly mention a specific data point (e.g., India's 5% of global biodiversity across 2.4% land area necessitating landscape approaches) to strengthen the opening.
More Challenges
View All- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
15 Feb, 2026
Discuss the significance of the relocation of the Prime Minister’s Office to the Seva Teerth complex under the Central Vista Redevelopment Project. How do the associated welfare and economic measures reflect the government’s vision of governance and development?
- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
13 Feb, 2026
Discuss the need for a permanent and objective framework for state reorganisation in India. How have the criteria for state formation evolved from linguistic considerations to developmental and administrative concerns?
- View Challenge
GS2
SOCIAL_ISSUES_AND_SCHEMES
12 Feb, 2026
Discuss the significance of the PM-SURAJ Portal in promoting inclusive entrepreneurship among marginalized communities in India.
