Score:
5.5/10
Analyze what earned this score 🔥
Topper’s Copy
GS2
International Relations
10 marks
Discuss the significance of India’s willingness to assist Afghanistan in hydroelectric projects in the context of regional stability and India’s foreign policy objectives.
Student’s Answer
Evaluation by SuperKalam
Demand of the Question
- Significance for regional stability
- Alignment with India's foreign policy objectives
- Context of hydroelectric projects assistance
- India's willingness and commitment analysis
What you wrote:
India and Afghanistan share deep, ancient historical ties spanning millennia. These connections are rooted in geography, culture, religion and trade. India's recent expression of willingness to assist Afghanistan in hydroelectric projects (2024-25) reflects its commitment to regional stability, humanitarian support, and development partnership.
[DRAWING:
A flowchart with the central theme "India's Engagement in Afghanistan".
From this, an arrow points to "Hydroelectric Cooperation".
Three arrows stem from "Hydroelectric Cooperation":
1. Points to "Development", which then points to "Better livelihoods".
2. Points to "Stability", which then points to "Regional Peace".
3. Points to "Diplomacy", which then points to "Strategic Goodwill".
]
India and Afghanistan share deep, ancient historical ties spanning millennia. These connections are rooted in geography, culture, religion and trade. India's recent expression of willingness to assist Afghanistan in hydroelectric projects (2024-25) reflects its commitment to regional stability, humanitarian support, and development partnership.
[DRAWING:
A flowchart with the central theme "India's Engagement in Afghanistan".
From this, an arrow points to "Hydroelectric Cooperation".
Three arrows stem from "Hydroelectric Cooperation":
1. Points to "Development", which then points to "Better livelihoods".
2. Points to "Stability", which then points to "Regional Peace".
3. Points to "Diplomacy", which then points to "Strategic Goodwill".
]
Suggestions to improve:
- Could specify the strategic importance of Afghanistan's location as a gateway between South and Central Asia
- Can mention the Taliban's return to power in 2021 as additional context for India's diplomatic engagement
What you wrote:
Significance of Projects in Regional Stability
1) Promoting Development for Peace: Hydroelectric projects like the Shahtoot Dam and Salma (Afghan-India Friendship) Dam enhance water supply, irrigation and electricity, directly improving livelihoods and reducing conflict drivers.
2) Regional Connectivity: Stable energy infrastructure supports South-Central Asian trade corridors, complementing projects like Chabahar Port and International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC).
3) Countering Extremism Through Development: India's development-led model provides a soft alternative to militarization, fostering goodwill and economic interdependence.
Significance of Projects in Regional Stability
1) Promoting Development for Peace: Hydroelectric projects like the Shahtoot Dam and Salma (Afghan-India Friendship) Dam enhance water supply, irrigation and electricity, directly improving livelihoods and reducing conflict drivers.
2) Regional Connectivity: Stable energy infrastructure supports South-Central Asian trade corridors, complementing projects like Chabahar Port and International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC).
3) Countering Extremism Through Development: India's development-led model provides a soft alternative to militarization, fostering goodwill and economic interdependence.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could elaborate on water scarcity challenges in Afghanistan (affecting 80% of population) and how hydroelectric projects address this crisis
- Can mention India's role in capacity building through training Afghan engineers and technicians
- Could highlight how stable energy supply reduces refugee outflows to neighboring countries, enhancing regional stability
What you wrote:
Alignment with India's Foreign Policy Objectives
1) Balancing Regional influence: Counter Pakistan's dominance and provides a constructive counter-narrative to China's Belt and Road Initiative.
2) Historical Ties: Builds upon India's decades long friendship since the Salma Dam (2016) and education and health projects across Afghanistan.
3) Soft Power Diplomacy: Developmental & humanitarian partner.
Alignment with India's Foreign Policy Objectives
1) Balancing Regional influence: Counter Pakistan's dominance and provides a constructive counter-narrative to China's Belt and Road Initiative.
2) Historical Ties: Builds upon India's decades long friendship since the Salma Dam (2016) and education and health projects across Afghanistan.
3) Soft Power Diplomacy: Developmental & humanitarian partner.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could connect to India's "Neighborhood First" policy and its application despite Taliban governance
- Can mention alignment with "Development Partnership" approach as part of India's South-South cooperation
- Could discuss how this engagement supports India's strategic autonomy by maintaining independent foreign policy despite international isolation of Taliban
- Can reference India's humanitarian assistance (wheat shipments, medical supplies) as part of comprehensive engagement strategy
What you wrote:
India's readiness to aid Afghanistan's hydroelectric development showcases its pursuit of peace through partnership, reinforcing its long-standing commitment to Afghan welfare & regional stability.
India's readiness to aid Afghanistan's hydroelectric development showcases its pursuit of peace through partnership, reinforcing its long-standing commitment to Afghan welfare & regional stability.
Suggestions to improve:
- Could emphasize India's pragmatic diplomacy in engaging with de facto authorities while maintaining humanitarian focus
- Can mention India's vision of "Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam" (world as one family) guiding its approach to regional cooperation
Strong answer demonstrating good understanding of India-Afghanistan relations with effective use of visual representation. The response addresses key demands but could benefit from deeper analysis of foreign policy frameworks and recent diplomatic developments.
Demand of the Question
- Significance for regional stability
- Alignment with India's foreign policy objectives
- Context of hydroelectric projects assistance
- India's willingness and commitment analysis
What you wrote:
India and Afghanistan share deep, ancient historical ties spanning millennia. These connections are rooted in geography, culture, religion and trade. India's recent expression of willingness to assist Afghanistan in hydroelectric projects (2024-25) reflects its commitment to regional stability, humanitarian support, and development partnership.
[DRAWING:
A flowchart with the central theme "India's Engagement in Afghanistan".
From this, an arrow points to "Hydroelectric Cooperation".
Three arrows stem from "Hydroelectric Cooperation":
1. Points to "Development", which then points to "Better livelihoods".
2. Points to "Stability", which then points to "Regional Peace".
3. Points to "Diplomacy", which then points to "Strategic Goodwill".
]
India and Afghanistan share deep, ancient historical ties spanning millennia. These connections are rooted in geography, culture, religion and trade. India's recent expression of willingness to assist Afghanistan in hydroelectric projects (2024-25) reflects its commitment to regional stability, humanitarian support, and development partnership.
[DRAWING:
A flowchart with the central theme "India's Engagement in Afghanistan".
From this, an arrow points to "Hydroelectric Cooperation".
Three arrows stem from "Hydroelectric Cooperation":
1. Points to "Development", which then points to "Better livelihoods".
2. Points to "Stability", which then points to "Regional Peace".
3. Points to "Diplomacy", which then points to "Strategic Goodwill".
]
Suggestions to improve:
- Could specify the strategic importance of Afghanistan's location as a gateway between South and Central Asia
- Can mention the Taliban's return to power in 2021 as additional context for India's diplomatic engagement
More Challenges
View All- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
29 Nov, 2025
Critically examine the Election Commission’s stance on simultaneous elections in India, especially with reference to the basic structure doctrine and election-related institutional mechanisms.
- View Challenge
GS2
Governance
Yesterday
Critically examine the limitations of the POSH Act in addressing sexual harassment in educational institutions, especially in cases involving power imbalance and emotional manipulation. Suggest reforms.
- View Challenge
GS2
Indian Polity
27 Nov, 2025
With the rise of deepfake technologies and AI-generated content, discuss the challenges they pose to personality rights in India. Evaluate the adequacy of existing legal frameworks and suggest measures to ensure stronger protection.
