Key Highlights
SCs Remarks on Rural Development Priorities
- SC dismissed a plea to direct States to set up public libraries in every village.
- Justice Surya Kant emphasized basic amenities like hygiene, education, and healthcare must take precedence in rural infrastructure.
- Libraries are important but not the most urgent rural requirement.
Budgetary Allocation Direction
- Court stated that 10%15% of States budgets must be earmarked for basic rural infrastructure to realize development goals.
Perspective on Libraries
- Libraries help spread constitutional and civic values but are secondary to urgent needs like mid-day meals, water, and schooling infrastructure.
- Petitioner NGO was asked if it had conducted surveys on health and education availability, highlighting the need for data-backed petitions.
India-specific Angle
- SC urged States to prioritize as per local realities, considering both constitutional literacy and ground-level needs.
- Emphasized need for policy discretion by States, not judicial imposition on budget decisions.
Mains Mock Question:
"Discuss the role of the judiciary in shaping public policy priorities in India. Should the courts direct States on budgetary allocations? Substantiate with examples."