EthicsGS 2: GovernanceGS 2: PolityPrelimsGS 2: Government policies and interventions for development in various sectors

All-Too Fallible, Pg8

India defends death penalty at UN, facing scrutiny over rising death row inmates and flawed judicial safeguards, prompting calls for abolition.

Practice MCQs

746 Students attempted
Attempt Now

Key Highlights:

  • India voted against a global moratorium on the death penalty at the UN, maintaining its consistent stance on the issue.
  • The country defends its retention of capital punishment as a sovereign decision backed by judicial safeguards, including the rarest of rare doctrine.
  • As of December 31, 2025, India had 574 people on death row, marking the highest number since 2016.
  • Parliament expanded the number of capital offenses under the new Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, a move criticized as penal populism.
  • The 2015 Law Commission report, headed by Justice A.P. Shah, recommended abolishing the death penalty for all crimes except terrorism and waging war.

Detailed Insights:

  • India's claim that due process fully protects individuals facing execution is questioned, despite the legal validity of distinguishing judicial executions from extrajudicial killings.
  • The Supreme Court has increasingly restricted capital punishment, and research indicates no additional deterrent effect compared to life imprisonment.
  • The expansion of capital offenses under Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita is seen as a political response to public outrage, particularly in cases of sexual violence.
  • This expansion often overlooks systemic issues like poor policing and low conviction rates, which are actual impediments to deterrence.
  • Data from Project 39A shows that between 2016 and 2025, the Supreme Court released 38 individuals from death row after they had spent an average of eight years there.
  • The criminal justice system's fallibility, including flawed evidence and unequal access to legal representation, undermines the infallibility required for capital punishment.
  • Recommendations include formally suspending executions, commissioning a review of penalty statutes, and sparing offenses not involving intentional killing from capital punishment.
  • The broader objective should be to abolish the death penalty in law while simultaneously improving investigative practices, prosecutorial standards, and access to legal aid.

Key Concepts Involved:

  • Rarest of rare doctrine: A legal principle in India dictating that the death penalty should be imposed only in exceptional cases where the crime is of extreme brutality.
  • Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita: A new criminal code enacted in India, replacing the Indian Penal Code, which has expanded the scope of capital offenses.
  • Penal populism: A political strategy where policies related to crime and punishment are adopted to appeal to popular sentiment rather than based on evidence or effectiveness.
  • Law Commission of India: An executive body that advises the Government of India on legal reforms and reviews existing laws.
SuperKalam
SuperKalam is your personal mentor for UPSC preparation, guiding you at every step of the exam journey.

Download the App

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Follow us

ⓒ Snapstack Technologies Private Limited