Q12. How would the recent phenomena of protectionism and currency manipulations in world trade affect the macroeconomic stability of India?

Model Answer:

Introduction

The recent phenomena of protectionism and currency manipulations in world trade have significant implications for the macroeconomic stability of India. 

Body

1. Economic Growth

• Protectionism: Increasing protectionist measures by major economies can lead to reduced access to international markets for Indian exporters. This can hinder growth in sectors that rely heavily on exports, such as textiles and pharmaceuticals. Slower growth in these sectors can have a cascading effect on overall GDP growth.
• Currency Manipulation: If other countries engage in currency manipulation to make their exports cheaper, Indian products may become less competitive in global markets. This could lead to a decline in export growth, impacting domestic production and employment rates.

2. Inflation and Price Stability

• Protectionism: Tariffs on imported goods can lead to higher prices for consumers, contributing to inflation. If essential goods are subjected to tariffs, this could disproportionately affect lower-income households, leading to increased social inequality.
• Currency Manipulation: If India’s currency appreciates due to other countries manipulating their currencies, imports may become cheaper, which could help control inflation. However, if India's currency depreciates as a result of global currency pressures, the cost of imports would rise, exacerbating inflationary pressures.

3. Foreign Investment

• Protectionism: A rise in protectionist policies worldwide may deter foreign direct investment (FDI) in India, as investors may perceive it as a less attractive market due to uncertainties in trade relations. A decline in FDI could affect sectors like infrastructure and manufacturing, which are crucial for economic growth.
• Currency Manipulation: If currency instability arises from manipulation, it can deter foreign investors who may be concerned about the volatility of returns. This could lead to a decline in portfolio investments and impact the capital markets negatively.

4. Trade Balance

• Protectionism: An increase in protectionist measures can lead to retaliation from trading partners, potentially resulting in trade wars. For India, this could disrupt its trade balance by reducing export opportunities while imports may remain high, leading to a worsening trade deficit.
• Currency Manipulation: If other nations devalue their currencies, it may lead to an increase in India’s trade deficit as imports become more expensive, while Indian exports become less competitive, adversely affecting the trade balance.

5. Employment and Labor Markets

• Protectionism: Job losses may occur in export-oriented industries due to decreased demand for Indian goods in foreign markets. Additionally, increased prices due to tariffs can lead to job losses in sectors reliant on imported materials.
• Currency Manipulation: Currency volatility can create uncertainty for businesses, leading to cautious hiring practices. If businesses anticipate lower demand due to currency manipulation effects, they may halt expansion plans, which could stifle job growth.

6. Policy Responses and Macroeconomic Management

• Protectionism: The Indian government may need to consider countermeasures to protect domestic industries, such as subsidies or strategic tariffs, which can create additional fiscal burdens. This may strain public finances and require adjustments in fiscal policy.
• Currency Manipulation: In response to currency manipulation by other nations, India may need to intervene in foreign exchange markets to stabilize its currency, which could deplete foreign reserves and create additional monetary policy challenges.

Conclusion

In summary, the phenomena of protectionism and currency manipulations present multiple challenges to India's macroeconomic stability. While these factors can lead to short-term protection for specific industries, they may result in broader negative consequences, including reduced economic growth, increased inflation, deterioration of the trade balance, and adverse impacts on employment. Policymakers in India will need to navigate these complexities carefully to maintain macroeconomic stability and foster sustainable economic growth.

‍

Instant Mains Evaluation with SuperKalam

✅ Now that you have gone through the model answer, try practicing and writing it in your own words and evaluate it instantly with SuperKalam here - Evaluate Mains Answer instantly