Q3. In view of the declining average size of land holdings in India which has made agriculture non–viable for a majority of farmers should contract farming and land leasing be promoted in agriculture? Critically evaluate the pros and cons.

Model Answer:

Introduction

In India, the average size of land holdings has been shrinking over the years due to population pressure, fragmentation, and inheritance laws. This has resulted in a majority of farmers owning marginal and small holdings, making agriculture less viable. In this context, contract farming and land leasing are seen as potential solutions to enhance agricultural productivity, increase incomes, and ensure sustainable farming practices. 

Body

Contract Farming and Land Leasing: Pros and Cons

Pros:

1. Assured Market and Price Stability: Contract farming provides farmers with an assured market for their produce and predetermined prices, reducing uncertainties and price volatility.
2. Access to Inputs and Technology: Companies engaging in contract farming often provide high-quality seeds, fertilizers, and modern technology, improving productivity and reducing input costs.
3. Risk Sharing: The buyer often shares the risks of crop failure or price fluctuations, which reduces the financial burden on small farmers.
4. Flexibility: Land leasing provides flexibility to farmers, allowing them to lease land for short-term or long-term purposes, depending on their financial situation.
5. Reduction of Fragmentation: Leasing can temporarily consolidate fragmented landholdings, improving farm efficiency and reducing operational costs.

Cons:

1. Exploitation of Farmers: Power imbalances between companies and small farmers can lead to unfair contracts, delayed payments, or even contract breaches.
2. Loss of Autonomy: Farmers may lose decision-making power over their land and what crops to grow, as contracts often specify particular crops and inputs.
3. Risk of Corporate Monopolization: There is the potential for large corporations to monopolize local markets, reducing competition and harming smaller traders.  
4. Eviction Risks: In the absence of strong tenancy laws, tenant farmers may face eviction, especially if land values rise or landowners choose to farm their land themselves.
5. Land Degradation: Tenants may overexploit the land for short-term gains, leading to soil degradation and reduced fertility in the long run. 

Conclusion

Contract farming and land leasing have the potential to improve the viability of agriculture in India, particularly for small and marginal farmers. However, their success depends on creating a regulatory environment that protects farmers' interests, ensures fair contracts, and promotes sustainable agricultural practices.  

‍

Instant Mains Evaluation with SuperKalam