Q15. Two parallel run schemes of the Government, viz the Adhar card and NPR, one of voluntary and the other as compulsory, have led to debates at national levels and also litigations. On merits , discuss whether or not both schemes need to run concurrently. Analyse the potential of the schemes to achieve development benefits and equitable growth.

Model Answer:

Introduction

The Aadhaar card and the National Population Register (NPR) are two significant initiatives undertaken by the Government of India aimed at improving governance and enhancing service delivery. While Aadhaar operates as a voluntary identification system, the NPR is a compulsory register aimed at documenting all residents. The concurrent implementation of both schemes has sparked debates and legal challenges regarding privacy, security, and the implications for equitable growth. This analysis evaluates the merits of running both schemes simultaneously and their potential development benefits.

Body

Arguments for Concurrent Implementation

• Complementary Objectives: Both schemes serve different yet complementary purposes. Aadhaar provides a unique identification number to individuals, facilitating access to services and benefits, while the NPR aims to maintain an accurate population database for planning and resource allocation.
• Enhanced Data Accuracy: Running both schemes concurrently can enhance the accuracy and reliability of demographic data. Aadhaar can serve as a verification tool within the NPR, reducing instances of duplication and fraud.
• Streamlined Service Delivery: The integration of Aadhaar with the NPR can streamline service delivery across various government schemes, enabling efficient targeting of beneficiaries and reducing leakages in welfare programs.
• Informed Policy Making: A comprehensive population database (NPR) enriched by Aadhaar data can enable better policy formulation and implementation, ensuring that government interventions are based on accurate demographic insights.

Concerns and Challenges

• Privacy and Security Issues: The simultaneous implementation raises concerns regarding data privacy and the security of sensitive information. There are fears of misuse of data and surveillance, which can undermine trust in government systems.
• Compulsory Nature of NPR: The mandatory requirement of the NPR may lead to exclusion of marginalised communities, particularly if they lack documentation. This can exacerbate inequalities rather than promote equitable growth.
• Legal and Ethical Implications: Ongoing litigations reflect significant public concern about civil liberties and human rights. The government must address these issues to ensure that both schemes are perceived as fair and just.

Conclusion

‍While the concurrent implementation of the Aadhaar card and NPR can offer several development benefits, including enhanced service delivery and informed policymaking, it also poses challenges related to privacy, security, and inclusivity. For these schemes to achieve their intended objectives of equitable growth and development, the government must prioritise transparency, address legal concerns, and ensure that marginalised populations are not excluded. A balanced approach that respects individual rights while promoting efficient governance is essential for maximising the potential of both initiatives.

‍

Instant Mains Evaluation with SuperKalam

‍