Introduction

Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) form the backbone of urban governance and development in India, established under the 74th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992. However, a recent report by the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) flagged critical challenges, such as a 42% gap between resources and expenditure of ULBs across 18 states. Moreover, ULBs generate only 32% of their revenue independently, with the majority coming from central and state transfers.

What is the Constitutional Mandate and Structure of ULBs in India?

  1. 74th Amendment Act, 1992:
    • Added Part IX-A (Articles 243-P to 243-ZG) to the Constitution.
    • Introduced the 12th Schedule with 18 functional items for Municipalities.
  2. Three-Tier Urban Structure:
    • Municipal Corporations: For large cities with populations over 1 million.
    • Municipalities: For smaller urban areas with populations less than 1 million.
    • Nagar Panchayats: For transitional areas moving from rural to urban.
  3. Additional Urban Bodies:
    • Notified Area Committee: Govern fast-developing towns.
    • Cantonment Boards: For military and civilian coexistence in cantonment areas.
    • Port Trusts: Manage ports and provide civic amenities.
    • Special Purpose Agencies: Address specific urban needs like transport or housing.
  4. State Supervision:
    • ULBs function under state governments, which determine their roles, funds, and powers.
  5. District and Metropolitan Planning Committees:
    • Mandated under Articles 243ZD and 243ZE to consolidate urban and rural plans.

Significance of Urban Local Bodies in India

  1. Urban Planning and Infrastructure Development:
    • ULBs prepare master plans for cities, regulate land use, and oversee sustainable infrastructure projects.
  2. Service Delivery:
    • Provide critical civic services like water supply, sanitation, solid waste management, public health, and lighting.
  3. Grassroots Democracy:
    • ULBs encourage decentralization, empowering women and marginalized communities through reservations.
  4. Disaster Management and Emergency Response:
    • Act as first responders during natural disasters and emergencies (e.g., BMC during Mumbai floods and COVID-19).
  5. Citizen Participation:
    • Mechanisms like ward committees enable direct participation, aligning with Gandhiji’s vision of ‘Poorna Swaraj’.

Challenges Faced by Urban Local Bodies in India

1. Financial Challenges

  • Overreliance on Transfers: ULBs rely on central and state transfers for 68% of their funds.
  • Post-GST Revenue Loss: Subsumption of Octroi and local taxes reduced revenue. For instance, MCGM lost ₹7,000 crores annually.
  • Property Tax Underutilization: Indian ULBs raise only 10-11% of potential property tax revenue, compared to China’s 20-22%.
  • Narrow Taxation Powers: Unlike ULBs in the US or Denmark, Indian ULBs lack powers to levy comprehensive taxes.
  • Delayed State Finance Commissions (SFCs): Irregular SFC constitution leads to inconsistent fund allocation.

2. Functional Challenges

  • Parastatal Agencies: State agencies (e.g., urban development authorities) override ULBs, reducing autonomy.
  • Incomplete Devolution of Powers: States retain critical urban functions, limiting ULB authority.
  • Non-functional District Planning Committees: Many states fail to operationalize DPCs, hampering urban planning.
  • Fragmented Urban Governance: Coordination issues between multiple agencies hinder integrated urban development.
  • Absence of Holistic Urban Planning: Cities face unplanned urbanization, slum growth, and traffic congestion.

3. Administrative and Human Resource Challenges

  • Election Delays: Delays in ULB elections weaken accountability and governance (e.g., BBMP in Bangalore).
  • Bureaucratic Control: State-appointed municipal commissioners limit the power of elected representatives.
  • Staff Shortages: About 35% of municipal corporation posts remain vacant, leading to functional inefficiencies.
  • Corruption and Criminalization: Increasing corruption scandals and the rise of criminal elements in ULBs undermine trust.
  • Lack of Capacity Building: Inadequate training and expertise hinder the effectiveness of urban governance.

4. Resource and Functionality Challenges

  • Low Revenue Autonomy: ULBs lack independent resource mobilization, restricting urban development initiatives.
  • Coordination Gaps: Poor cooperation among local, state, and central authorities causes delays in project implementation.
  • Corruption and Accountability Issues: Inconsistent transparency laws lead to mismanagement of funds.
  • Inadequate Infrastructure Management: ULBs fail to modernize public infrastructure, affecting urban livability.
  • Citizen Grievance Redressal: Limited mechanisms to address grievances hinder civic engagement and trust.

Way Forward to Strengthen Urban Local Bodies

1. Financial Reforms

  • Enhance ULB autonomy to levy taxes and fully utilize property tax potential.
  • Regularize State Finance Commissions (SFCs) and ensure timely fund transfers.
  • Explore innovative funding mechanisms like municipal bonds and Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs).

2. Functional and Institutional Reforms

  • Implement recommendations of the 6th ARC and NITI Aayog for stronger ULBs.
  • Activate Metropolitan Planning Committees (MPCs) and District Planning Committees for integrated urban planning.
  • Strengthen urban governance frameworks with clear devolution of powers.

3. Capacity Building and Human Resources

  • Regularly conduct ULB elections to ensure accountability and democratic governance.
  • Address staff shortages by hiring skilled professionals and implementing training programs.
  • Promote e-Governance to improve efficiency, transparency, and service delivery.

4. Enhancing Citizen Participation

  • Empower ward committees and encourage partnerships with NGOs and civil society organizations.
  • Use technology for participatory governance (e.g., grievance portals, public consultations).

5. Strengthening Accountability and Transparency

  • Enforce the Public Disclosure Law across all states to improve civic data transparency.
  • Implement strict anti-corruption measures and monitor fund utilization.

Conclusion

Urban Local Bodies play a critical role in ensuring efficient urban governance, providing essential services, and promoting citizen participation. However, challenges like financial dependency, bureaucratic control, and lack of capacity hinder their effectiveness. Strengthening ULBs requires financial autonomy, functional devolution, capacity building, and active citizen engagement. A robust framework will enable ULBs to act as true instruments of democratic decentralization, driving sustainable urban development in India.

‍

Weekly News Analysis by SuperKalam

Stay updated with our weekly news analysis on YouTube - Check here

‍

Read more blogs