Q19. What are the key areas of reform if the WTO has to survive in the present context of ‘Trade War’, especially keeping in mind the interest of India?

Model Answer:

Introduction

The World Trade Organization (WTO) has been at the forefront of regulating international trade since its establishment in 1995. However, it faces significant challenges, particularly due to the rise of protectionism and trade wars between major economies. To ensure its survival and relevance, especially for developing countries like India, the WTO must undergo key reforms.

Body

Key Areas of Reform:

• Dispute Settlement Mechanism:
  • Current Situation: The WTO's dispute resolution process has been crippled by the inability to appoint judges to the Appellate Body, primarily due to US objections.
  • Reform Need: Immediate reforms are required to restore functionality. This includes a clear, binding mechanism for dispute resolution that addresses concerns of member states while ensuring impartiality.
  • India’s Interest: India has historically relied on the dispute settlement system to defend its trade interests, particularly in agriculture and textiles. A robust system would protect these sectors from unfair trade practices.
• Special and Differential Treatment (S&DT):
  • Current Situation: Developed nations have been advocating for a re-evaluation of S&DT provisions, which allow developing countries flexibility in adhering to WTO rules.
  • Reform Need: Preserving S&DT is crucial for developing nations to protect their economic interests while enabling a gradual integration into the global trading system.
  • India’s Interest: As a developing economy, India depends on S&DT for its agricultural policies and to support its domestic industries against global competition.
• Trade Rules on Digital Economy:
  • Current Situation: With the exponential growth of digital trade, the WTO lacks a comprehensive framework to address issues like e-commerce, data privacy, and cybersecurity.
  • Reform Need: Establishing clear, modern rules governing digital trade will facilitate cross-border e-commerce and address emerging challenges.
  • India’s Interest: India’s digital economy is booming, and having clear trade rules will enable its tech firms to expand globally without facing regulatory barriers.
• Addressing Agricultural Subsidies:
  • Current Situation: The WTO has been criticized for allowing developed countries to provide significant agricultural subsidies that distort trade.
  • Reform Need: Stricter rules should be implemented to ensure that all countries adhere to fair subsidy practices, promoting a level playing field.
  • India’s Interest: Indian farmers face challenges from subsidised products from developed nations. Reforming subsidy rules will help protect their livelihoods and promote fair competition.
• Sustainability and Environmental Standards:
  • Current Situation: Trade rules have not adequately addressed environmental sustainability, with increasing concerns about climate change.
  • Reform Need: Incorporating sustainability into WTO agreements will align trade policies with global climate goals, promoting environmentally friendly practices.
  • India’s Interest: As a nation vulnerable to climate change impacts, India would benefit from trade policies that support sustainable development while pursuing its economic growth.
• Inclusiveness and Transparency:
  • Current Situation: Developing countries often feel marginalised in WTO negotiations, leading to a lack of representation in decision-making processes.
  • Reform Need: Enhancing transparency and ensuring that developing nations have a voice in negotiations will rebuild trust in the WTO.
  • India’s Interest: Greater representation will allow India to advocate for its interests more effectively, particularly in negotiations impacting agricultural and industrial sectors.

Conclusion

For the WTO to survive in the current climate of trade wars, comprehensive reforms are essential. By focusing on dispute resolution, maintaining special treatment for developing countries, addressing digital trade, reforming agricultural subsidies, incorporating sustainability, and ensuring inclusiveness, the WTO can adapt to changing global trade dynamics. For India, advocating for these reforms is crucial in securing its trade interests and ensuring that the WTO remains a relevant and effective platform for global trade governance.

‍

Instant Mains Evaluation with SuperKalam

✅ Now that you have gone through the model answer, try practicing and writing it in your own words and evaluate it instantly with SuperKalam here - Evaluate Mains Answer instantly